Astronomy and astrology have been historically treated together, but they gradually separated through the Late Middle Ages into the Age of Reason. Astrology began in Babylonia around two and a half millennia ago, with the Babylonians believing that planets and their motions influenced the fortunes of kings and nations. Astronomy was studied and practiced extensively during both ancient Babylonian and Egyptian civilizations, and its importance in human culture, reasoning, and philosophy is significant.
Despite differing beliefs surrounding its relative scientific merits, astrology in Ancient and Medieval times was closely linked with astronomy. Early astronomers, such as Ptolemy, practiced astrology alongside their scientific work. The zodiac signs and constellations bear names rooted in their historical context. Ancient forms of astrology often combined with astronomy, but eventually split into separate paths during the time of Copernicus, Kepler, and Galileo.
Astronomy and astrology were often practiced together in ancient cultures, and astrology played an important role in the historical development of astronomy. Astronomy was considered a scholarly tradition until the 17th century, and it helped drive the development of astronomy. It was also commonly accepted in political circles.
While astronomy and astrology are fundamentally different, there is a historical connection between them. Early astronomers, such as Ptolemy, often practiced astrology alongside their scientific work. Most people, even the popes at the time, relied on astrology and astrological predictions to make important decisions. Astrology and astrology have evolved over time, with the development of the Age of Reason and the rise of the Age of Reason.
📹 Astrology vs Astronomy: The Difference Between Astrology And Astronomy
Astrology vs Astronomy: If you are a newbie when it comes to space and it’s possible impact on our lives, this video will explain the …
What does Islam say about astrology?
The Hadith, a collection of Islamic religious teachings, is a significant part of the Islamic faith. It outlines the instructions and practices of Muhammad, who criticized the legality and illegality of astrology. According to Abu Dawud, seeking knowledge from the stars is considered witchcraft, which is inherently forbidden in Islam. The Hadith also emphasizes that rain is a blessing bestowed only by Allah, and any belief that rain is a result of other beings is considered disbelief.
The Hadith also mentions the stars, stating that those who suggest rain originates from a star are considered disbelievers in Allah. This concept of astrology and the belief in celestial beings’ influence on anything other than what is enshrined in the Quran and Hadith constitutes shirk (blasphemy) and leads one to leave the fold of the religion.
Second-century Islamic scholar Imam Ali, the fourth caliph of Islam and cousin and son-in-law of Muhammad, views astrology as fundamentally forbidden in the Islamic religion. He warns followers not to learn the science of stars except for guidance on land or sea, as it leads to divining and an astrologer is a diviner. This aligns with the Quran, which points to stars and astrology as only a means of navigation.
However, prominent scholars like Ibn Arabi and Ikhwan argue that planets are not considered God but do suggest each prophet with a specific planet/celestial being. Prophet Idris, also known as Enoch, was gifted with great knowledge of the stars and used his gift to meditate upon God’s grandeur and teach others. He believed that the stars and moon contributed to mankind and founded the study of the stars.
Different sects of Islam offer varying perspectives on the concept of astrology.
Why is astronomy not astrology?
Astronomy is a scientific field that studies celestial bodies outside the Earth’s atmosphere, such as planets, stars, asteroids, and galaxies. Astronomers study these celestial bodies through research and observation. Astrology posits that the positioning of stars and planets affects Earth’s events. Astronomers are interested in the solar system, planets, asteroids, comets, galaxies, the universe, space, and the possibility of alien life or space travel.
What is the relationship between astrology and astronomy?
Astrology, a branch of astronomy, was once considered a science, focusing on understanding the influence of stars on earthly events. Scholars like Abu Ma’shar al-Balkhi, al-Biruni, and Nasir al-Din al-Tusi wrote astrological treatises. Observational astronomy flourished in the Islamic world, where sophisticated observatories and instruments were developed. Caliph al-Ma’mun built the first observatory in Baghdad in the ninth century, allowing astronomers to prepare tables describing the motions of the sun and moon, star catalogues, and descriptions of instruments used.
The accuracy of medieval Islamic observatories and astronomical instruments was remarkable, with calculations in famous observatories in Samarqand and Maragha differing by only a fraction of a percent. Scientists working under Islamic patronage also developed smaller portable tools such as the astrolabe, the astrolabic quadrant, and the celestial globe. The astrolabic quadrant was used to record the location of stars and planets in the celestial sphere, while the celestial globe was used for teaching and illustrative purposes.
These portable tools made their way into Renaissance Europe, aiding in the development of similar astronomic instruments by European scientists. Italian and Flemish scholars produced detailed drawings of Near Eastern astrolabes, including refined reproductions of engraved Arabic inscriptions, demonstrating knowledge of Arabic and an avid interest in Islamic instruments in sixteenth-century Europe.
Is astronomy haram in Islam?
The Holy Qur’an is a revelation that encourages people to think about the world around them and the signs of Allah. It contains scientific knowledge that has taken centuries to discover, and it is believed to be divinely originating. Muslims believe that the Qur’an is the actual word of Allah, the Most High. A proper understanding of the Qur’an requires an understanding of science, as it encourages reflection on the works of creation to realize the greatness of Almighty God.
There is a distinction between Astronomy and Astrology, which are often confused as meaning the same. Astronomy is a science and halal, while Astrology is a pseudo science and haram. Astronomy studies the heavens to understand the underlying principles governing planets, stars, galaxies, and the Universe in general. Astrology claims to predict the destinies of persons based on the actions of planets. There has been no contradiction between Astronomy and the Qur’an.
The Qur’an deals with various areas of science, including earth geology, animal and vegetable kingdom, human reproduction, and Astronomy. This article focuses on the position of Astronomy in Islam, emphasizing observed facts over theories. Theories can be subjective and may be modified, changed, or rejected based on observational data. Understanding the underlying principles behind the universe provides a deeper sense of awe and appreciation for the One who created it.
Is astrology older than astronomy?
Astronomy and astrology are ancient Greek words with roots in disaster, meaning “star”. Astronomy is the study of objects and matter outside the Earth’s atmosphere, while astrology is the divination of the supposed influences of stars and planets on human affairs and terrestrial events. Astrology is related to astrologaster, a term that was once a derogatory term for someone who purported to study the stars. In modern use, the two words have different meanings, but for hundreds of years, they were synonymous.
The word “supposed” in astrology indicates that astrologers’ claims are widely viewed as unscientific and serves as a placeholder for the screams of anguish from science teachers when students confuse astronomy and astrology.
Has the astronomy and the astrology something in common?
Astronomers and astrologers view Earth as an integral part of the universe, interconnected as one cosmos. Astrologers view the cosmos as having a supernatural, metaphysical, and divine essence that influences world events and personal lives. Astronomers cannot use explanations derived from empirically reproducible conditions in their scientific articles. Funding from astrology supported astronomical research, which was used to create more accurate ephemerides for astrology.
In Medieval Europe, Astronomia was used to encompass both disciplines, with court astrologers employed by rulers to aid in decision-making and university medical students taught astrology. Astronomy and astrology diverged between the 17th and 19th centuries, with Copernicus not practicing astrology or empirical astronomy, but Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler, and Galileo Galilei being the most important astronomers before Isaac Newton.
Can astronomy and astrology work together?
Astrology, a scientific theory, has been criticized by many as a false representation of the universe and a pseudoscience. However, its followers argue that it is connected to human life and spirituality, and that the movement of celestial bodies can be associated with human emotions like drive and courage. The most popular form of astrology is seen in horoscopes, which are exposed to people through social media, news outlets, and digital media.
In ancient times, astrology was often combined with astronomy but eventually split into separate paths during the time of Copernicus, Kepler, and Galileo. Zodiac signs in modern times are constructed from constellations and used to associate human emotions and tendencies with stars and heavenly bodies. These signs can be considered a pseudo-religion due to the emphasis on the meanings of constellations and their relationship to each individual.
The popularity of horoscopes is largely due to cultural developments, such as the internet, which allows for easy access to information on them. Many individuals interested in horoscopes are unaware that the signs and their dates are inaccurate and do not have any basis in science. However, the “trendy” nature of zodiac signs and their popularity make them widely recognized as part of global culture.
The history of astronomy includes the Natal chart, Panchangam, The Sophia Centre, and Treatise on the Astrolabe. Astrology has evolved over time, with the rise of the internet and the rise of social media platforms providing easy access to information about horoscopes.
What caused the split between astronomy and astrology?
Astronomy emerged due to the desire to predict the future using celestial bodies. Ancient civilizations like the Babylonians and Romans recognized celestial objects’ influence on Earth’s environment, such as the sun’s movement. However, they often attributed too much celestial influence to the gods, believing outer space to be the realm of celestial events. The Enlightenment period in the 1600s and 1700s marked a significant split between astronomy and astrology.
The first telescopes and Isaac Newton’s laws of motion and gravity helped explain outer space phenomena. Both fields use terms like constellations, the zodiac, solstices, and conjunctions, but for different reasons.
Are astronomy and astrology connected?
Astrology, a branch of astronomy, was once considered a science, focusing on understanding the influence of stars on earthly events. Scholars like Abu Ma’shar al-Balkhi, al-Biruni, and Nasir al-Din al-Tusi wrote astrological treatises. Observational astronomy flourished in the Islamic world, where sophisticated observatories and instruments were developed. Caliph al-Ma’mun built the first observatory in Baghdad in the ninth century, allowing astronomers to prepare tables describing the motions of the sun and moon, star catalogues, and descriptions of instruments used.
The accuracy of medieval Islamic observatories and astronomical instruments was remarkable, with calculations in famous observatories in Samarqand and Maragha differing by only a fraction of a percent. Scientists working under Islamic patronage also developed smaller portable tools such as the astrolabe, the astrolabic quadrant, and the celestial globe. The astrolabic quadrant was used to record the location of stars and planets in the celestial sphere, while the celestial globe was used for teaching and illustrative purposes.
These portable tools made their way into Renaissance Europe, aiding in the development of similar astronomic instruments by European scientists. Italian and Flemish scholars produced detailed drawings of Near Eastern astrolabes, including refined reproductions of engraved Arabic inscriptions, demonstrating knowledge of Arabic and an avid interest in Islamic instruments in sixteenth-century Europe.
Who combined the practice of astrology and astronomy?
Ptolemy, a prominent astronomer and astrologer, distinguished between the two disciplines. Astronomy focused on the mathematical analysis of celestial movements, while astrology studied the impact of star configuration on the sublunary world. Ptolemy’s work on astronomy includes a list of known stars by constellation, indicating their position in the sky. He distinguished between the two disciplines to provide a comprehensive understanding of the sky.
Did astronomy come from astrology?
Astrology, a scholarly tradition among West Eurasian peoples, dates back to the 3rd millennium BC. It originated from calendrical systems used to predict seasonal shifts and interpret celestial cycles as divine communications. Until the 17th century, astrology was accepted in political and cultural circles and was used in other traditional studies like alchemy, meteorology, and medicine. However, by the end of the 17th century, emerging scientific concepts in astronomy, such as heliocentrism, undermined the theoretical basis of astrology, leading to its loss of academic standing and becoming regarded as a pseudoscience.
In the 20th century, astrology gained broader consumer popularity through mass media products like newspaper horoscopes. Babylonian astrology is the earliest recorded organized system of astrology, arising in the 2nd millennium BC. Although there is speculation that astrology appeared in the Sumerian period in the 3rd millennium BC, the isolated references to ancient celestial omens are not sufficient evidence to demonstrate an integrated theory. The history of scholarly celestial divination generally begins with late Old Babylonian texts (c. 1800 BC) and continues through the Middle Babylonian and Middle Assyrian periods (c. 1200 BC).
📹 Astrology isn’t science, but your horoscope is more real than you think
Astrology isn’t real science, but there’s more to the zodiac than ancient superstition. Before horoscopes were popularly debunked, …
In the past and sometimes even know astrology is extremely important for determining what is North south east and west or what the time of the year is or where you are. Many people used the North Star for long distance travel into unknown territory or for less proof of them being there. Astronomy is of course very important, it can show the farthest point in history and eventually, we might be able to see the future but that’s probably not gonna happen for another couple thousand years or might never, but I’m sure it’s possible but also you could create a wormhole 1 minute and then create another and it would become a cloning machine or if we can create like a system we could be like in the future, sure I will visit World War III or I really miss my dog, I’m going back to see him/her. Harnessing space creates limitless opportunities just like space is limitless. I just started thinking and this happened… thinking is scary.
Madam i do not what Western Astrology rules are or how they calculate the zodiac and constellation and all. But I would like to suggest you to read Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra – The most Authentic text written on Vedic Jyotish by Sage Parashar. You’ll get all your Answers of wrong calculations you’re doing. Astrology like others subjects have different systems and usage of different Ayanamsas. People believe in astronomy which is also a part of astrology as well. And the calculations our sages had done at their time was far superior than even compare to calculations done by today’s technology. And yes Astrology is real and it exist like the air we breathe and yes the zodiac and planets affect us but we all have different karmic patterns and different natals that is why the effects have variations. People often use astrology as remedial science which is wrong. Astrology is a guiding tool not a remedial tool. It’s not a predictive science it’s a corrective science. And it’s more of a mathematics than science. What i would like to say is that first get the information of Astrology then argue or defame that subject.
my only issue with astrology is when people use it to excuse their poor behaviour and judge people based on their signs. i like astrology, i think it’s cool. but really, shit’s gotta stop at a certain point. edit: i’ve worded out my comment wrongly. no, i don’t have an issue with astrology but i have an issue WITH people misusing astrology by judging people solely based on that. and it’s cool if you believe in it. i don’t and i won’t ever. which is also fine. just respect each other down there.
The way I see it.. if you think about it on a fundamental level, astrology is just a reflection of the rhythms of the earth and how they influence a developing mind to form its personality. This is especially apparent with the sun sign; the sun influences the seasons, the seasons influence the weather and how we react to our environment, and a small little human brain soaks all those influences up and develops its identity around it. That’s why Scorpio reflects the death cycle of summer into fall. That’s why Taurus reflects the sensual and creative principle of the first true buds of spring. That’s why Capricorn represents the hardship and struggle of the middle of winter. That’s why Leo represents the vibrancy, glow, and heat of summer. Etc… It’s all just rhythms and archetypes. Science is prone to looking down on it because it doesn’t value knowledge that does not fit into its systems. It’s just a different type of knowledge, one just as valid, albeit a bit more fluid.
This comment will probably get buried but if anyone is interested, look into vedic astrology. That method reads the sky differently so your sun sign will seem whacky, but it’s even more in depth then western astrology. They have divisional charts, dasas, nakshatra, etc, and is a little more scientific then just seeing your chart and houses since they also calculate things about early/later life and time periods within your life.
I believe that astrology maybe can’t predict stuff like it tries to do in horoscopes (like “you’re going to find the love of your life tomorrow”) but it definitely affects people’s personality and behavior. Astrology has helped me to understand myself better, it made me see things about my personality that I didn’t see before, and it’s great. It has also helped me understand others, and how I can communicate with them.
Ok well I’m just gonna say it. Every single two faced person I ever met was a Gemini. (THERE ARE SOME VERY ANNOYING BUTTHURT PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD SO LET ME ASSURE YOU THAT THIS IS TO BE TAKEN AS A JOKE, NOW PLEASE KEEP SCROLLING IF YOURE GONNA REPLY THAT IM A B*TCH BECAUSE YOURE A GEMINI AND YOURE THE NICEST PERSON ON EARTH THANK YOU)
I find astrology to be incredibly fascinating and helpful when it comes to developing your self-awareness. I believe our birth charts act as mirrors and ask you to take a deeper look into our characteristics and psyche. It encourages growth and introspection by highlighting the parts of your character that may need extra work and focus in order to reach your highest potential. Horoscopes are false the majority of the time because you’ll have one person picking up on the energy of hundreds of people with your same sun sign (which is only one aspect of your chart), and we are all on different paths/ timing so of course it will not be accurate. I encourage people to look into astrology, aside from actually being a great self development tool ( really calls you out on your bullshit and brings plenty of moments of realization) to really look into it, and not just take it in at surface level, it’s a lot of fun as well getting to know ones self; parts that you may have known were there, but never recognized as tendencies— a great reminder of who you are; your impact as a human being, and the universe around you.
Not the candy astrologies you see on the web all the time. You need to have your horoscope done by a professional using your birthdate, location, and time of birth. Through that, I learned that I have Venus in the second house, this explained why I care so much about making my surroundings and atmosphere beautiful and love to buy things like beautiful antique furnitures, flowers, luxury curtains etc. to make my surroundings beautiful. Venus in the second house also advice a career that involve arts and beauty. This explained why I love to sing and wanted to become a fashion designer and singer. These comes naturally and I know that I will benefit in those fields. I also have Saturn in the eighth house, which states a hard childhood and lifelong struggles. This is very true for me as I had a very tough childhood and I am struggling with things that I could never get rid off or fix, that’s keeping me from happiness. They will probably last a lifetime. It also predict death by violence. John F. Kenny has Saturn in the 8th house. Its a hard life with Saturn in the 8th house. You can have traits of other signs as well depending on your charts and planets during the time of your birth. Astrology can explain why you are how you are and give good advice of what to do with your life.
psa: you have more than one sign, even then, still look at your houses, what planets are in the houses, what planets are in a certain sign (so you can know what to expect the next couple of months as of your personality), current retrogrades etc. there’s a lot but it’s so interesting how your personality aligns with the planets and how they’re acting
I hate how so many people judge astrology when they don’t know anything about it. edit: I was raised with it and know a lot more than most people (grew spiritual, etc…). I know that Astrology is so much deeper than what people put on social media. It’s more than the idealism on social media (It telling you about your love life, etc…). Yes, you could see about your love life but Astrology is for self discovery, self-understanding and to know the shadow part of us and whatever else there is, everyone can use Astrology for whatever they want. It’s okay if you don’t want to believe planets or comets have any effect on us. I simply dislike how people believe they know everything about Astrology because they know their sun sign… I dislike that people judge it even though they don’t know what they are judging. You don’t have to like it, just don’t judge because it’s unknown to you. Astrology has been around for thousands of years and has only recently been making a comeback.
astrology is harmless, i dont get why nonbelievers attack us for something we like doing, we dont come up to you with your ideas calling you loud names for something we find interest in. yeah astrology is bs, but it makes me connect in life and has helped me make a better impact in myself what i need to work on to be a better person, twitter and insta astrology isnt real astrology, its memes, just like the other things you post on social medias that are memes, go into the studies in a different level than a one page level.
I really hate when people assume astrology is only about 12 zodiac signs. “Oh, so you’re Sagittarius guy? You should not go with Gemini girl.” Then it’s no different than MBTI. That’s shallow and lazy. I love astronomy, astrology (western and Chinese), and mythology, and read a lot about them. Yes, astrology is still not considered science. But I tried different approach to it : psychology. I think, astrology can be used to read human behaviour, motivation, positive traits, negative traits, etc. Like psychology, its information can be used to better oneself. And like psychology, it needs a lot of observation.
I like looking into astrology and I find the whole idea kind of fun especially when I actually resonate well with my sign in some aspects. But just like religion, I’d rather not take anything too seriously and your sign or someone else’s sign shouldn’t limit what you can and cannot do in life. At least that’s my personal take.
When I was little, I read up on Scorpio because people around me, without knowing when I was born, kept asking me if I was a Scorpio since I seemed very Scorpionic. I never trusted horoscopes since I found them so vague and nor care about trying to predict things anyways, but I did find an uncanny resemblance with myself and what was described in Scorpio. I later learned what cold reading was and how astrology and especially horoscopes use it to get broad, vague, but somewhat accurate predictions and got diagnosed with autism. Me having little to no interest in people, only ever read Scorpio and did use it to gain a pretty good understanding of myself pretty early on. Once my little interests in people started to give me problems, the ideas sparked through reading Scorpio did give me some language to work off of that did end up serving me quite well. Ideas such as intimacy, layers or protective walls, intensity, and natural “sting” against people I felt no connection to became handy when trying to navigate through the backwardness of social interaction and culture, as well as my natural tendency to be off putted by things others find attracting and vice versa. While I think this astrology stuff is mostly pretentious and non-scientific, I think there is some value in the ideas it raises and language it contains in order to achieve self-discovery and social understanding and navigation, but I never counted on this stuff on its own as I read up basically anything for me to understand the ever ubiquitous and ever backwards social sphere.
i always try to explain this to people, ive been slowly studying astrology more and more over the past 5 years and i don’t necessarily believe in it on a scientific standpoint but i love it so much because as someone who has struggled with social connections and verbalizing what’s going on in my head, it helps to give me a language that has helped me open up and discover myself and lean into who i am.
What I took from this article: Astrology and alchemy are pretty similar. Neither is a science (they are more akin to esoteric practices and magic and what not) but the fact that people have been interested in them has led to some milestones in the history of science Fun fact: the dude who discovered Phosphorus was an alchemist
I’m also a pieces and I don’t mind where we are on the list, all in all we’re all gonna die so it doesn’t really matter…cancers can be a compassionate and beautiful sign, as well as very protective this could be why they might sometimes seem or be a little bit manipulative… as they value and protect the people they love or hold dear, nonetheless, pisces ♓️ seems to be the most misunderstood star signs amongst all the zodiacs…which is fine, because I think we understand ourselves probably the most as well as others we communicate intimately with…all in all I don’t think we should take astronomy too seriously, it should be used as a tool to understand your own personal behaviors rather than a group or mass, that’s why I always say take it with a pinch of salt🧂 😊 Ps… all the star signs are amazing in there own way… it’s just that if the person or individual associated with theses signs stands for a good value or bad sometimes both
I’m a science nerd and love astrophysics, it fascinates, interests and scares me at the same time. I can listen to someone explaining anything from theory of relativity to gravitational fields and time warps for hours, but this does not automatically mean that I am not allowed to believe in something that we don’t fully understand or can’t prove. This universe is full of things, which don’t have a rational explanation. Why not open our minds a little bit more and accept a fact that we don’t and can’t know everything. The question is how much accurate and real is what we know? Science elitists are snobbish and narrow minded, self-righteous fanatics who don’t leave a room for doubt. It’s easy to hate something we don’t understand. This world is NOT just black and white and even science is based on lots of theories. Not believing in something does not mean it might not exist (or vice versa), just like absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
Very interesting, I love astronomy and now I’m starting to open up to the possibility of astrology having validity. Even in neuroscience something that emerged is epigenetics, which before seemed like pseudoscience but is now actually being studied by scientists, so maybe some day we will find some sort of correlation especially when you realize everything is intricately connected.
I personally think that superficial daily horoscope in magazines is mostly bs but if you dive deeper into astrology with sun/moon signs, place and time and everything that plays into it, it’s really interesting and can actually help you analyse yourself or understand yourself better (emphasis on CAN). For me it’s less abt future telling but more abt understanding certain personalities/myself.
Kind of disappointed you didn’t cover natal charts. What made me a believer was looking at my natal chart. Your birth actually consists of several different signs, and depending on which of the 12 houses those are based in, can clearly spell out your personality. It’s not just a 1 in 12 thing. It’s 1 in millions of different combinations that makes us how we are. There are scientists who believe that we are made out of stars, in a sense. It’s very interesting if one takes the time to look into how the basics of astrology actually work. It’s AMAZING what a natal chart can say. Try it! I use cafe astrology
In my teens, way before l learned about astrology, l was doing a quiz with a friend and he said he wanted to be king of the jungle. I said why? I’d never want that, it’s so pretentious, and cliché, and who has the time? l’d rather swing in a tree or swim down a river. This personality fits my Aries Sun. Years later l started learning about astrology and l learned that that friend had a Virgo Sun. There wasn’t much to note regarding him and his sign. A year on maybe l learned about all the planets in one’s natal chart. And l noticed that friend has LEO Mercury, so he may not BE a Leo, but he THINKS like a Leo, because Mercury is the way you think. So obviously he wants to be king of the jungle. Just like mike Tyson, he’s a Cancer so he’s more emotional, sensitive, round features, round shoulders and pecs, and a youthful energy but LEO MERCURY, he thinks like a lion, he’s dominant. And then there’s Donald Trump with Mercury in Cancer, he thinks and talks like an infant lol.
The comparisons between modern science and ancient/medieval ‘doctors’ who were using astrology are really far-fetched… it’s like saying that modern car manufacturers should learn from wooden sledges in ancient Egypt – yeah, there is a similarity, but it’s so distant and vague that the comparison doesn’t even make sense. Confirmation bias much?
For the people who say there are not enough variations for all the people in the world consider this. Two men are born at the same time, day, location but one ends up a king the other a metal smith. Astrology doesn’t affect whether or not you become a king/metal smith, that is due to circumstance, rather it influences how you react, adapt, respond to those influences. Most importantly he stars impel, not compel. Anything can be worked out of.
From my experience astrology is very real. I observe how people act and look and when I find out their signs it matches excacly with it. Aries people have certain looks and certain demeanors that make them who they are just like Leo’s, virgos, Scorpios, cancers and etc. alot of people don’t believe in astrology because they fail or refuse to look deeper into the subject.
I can’t speak for other people, but I can speak for myself. My sun sign, Cancer, and my moon sign, Virgo, are very evident to me. At the end of the day, astrology is a subjective topic, and whether or not you think it’s real or not depends on how you personally experience it. With no way to find a definite answer, everyones opinion is right and wrong at the same time. Personally, I do feel a connection with my sun and moon signs. They mean something to me and give me a possible reason as to why I can be the way I am, so I believe in astrology myself.
I came across astrology late in my life and I have to say I was blown away. All the study of my theme was done by myself and I never paid anyone for information. Being of a very introspective nature but also very skeptical, as always I decided to see for myself the veracity or not of this field. I tell you without any hesitation, my birth chart carries with it my personality and my wounds and even my family history. And it really came as a shock to realize that astrology was so much more than a story of fake clairvoyant horoscopes and quack predictions. Even things that didn’t make me happy and yet were necessary for me to understand. I’m really sad that people aren’t more curious than that, a saying goes that there are two ways of looking at life, the first is that everything is a miracle, the other that nothing ever is . I don’t think either of them is really right.
I use astrology as a map for people’s personalities coz I don’t know how to properly interact with others without unintentionally offending them. It never failed once haha the only reason why astrology garnered a terrible reputation is coz people only use the sun signs and it put people in small narrow boxes, when in reality there’s a bunch of stuff underneath that. You have a whole chart for you, basics include your rising, sun and moon and that could be any sign so you may be an aries but act like a virgo and feel like a cancer. there’s also the houses, degrees and etc so no one is the exact same. I personally really love it coz I could also learn how people think and perceive themselves but welp, even I couldn’t really tell if it’s all scientific or not as it’s just an empirical data. I’ve always been interested in astrology since I discovered so here I am during quarantine and learned more lol
I like to beleave in astrology because it lets me dive deeper into myself an others, I don’t just blindly assume everything I learn is true when my zodiac is considered, but I do question it Not interested in predictions or anything like that, but I do offden notice patterns in people that fit astrology I beleave everyone is diffrent, but there’s a sertin pattern we tend to follow in some way shape or form, sometimes the pattern isent there because people can pretty much be whoever they want, maybe it use to be there, or maybe it will always be there, people are so complex and unpredictable I can’t help but be fascinated
“It doesn’t actually matter if people believe in astrology, the better question (…) is whether it helps people” YES that’s what I’ve been saying forever, if someone came at me with the undeniable proof that it is all bullshit I wouldn’t care less, I don’t let it control my life, I use it as a tool to explain what I already know about myself
(This is written with google translator, sorry) I like astrology, as I like the Chinese calendar, Indian mythology and the Greek gods. my only problem with this is that it is based on dates, it makes you suggest yourself to be like your sign. I am cancer, and due to a traumatic event I tend to cry in stressful situations, I thought later that “oh well, cancer things” which delayed my necessary visit to the psychologist. I wonder how many people have inadvertently suggested themselves to be like his sign…
I like how this article is as conveniently vague and half arsed as astrology itself. Can’t believe people are actually responding positively to this. “That idea has made astrology an important medical tool for centuries.” You know what else was an “important medical tool” for centuries? Leeches. Just because something was/is prevalent doesn’t mean it’s correct.
Honestly i enjoyed your take on the subject, i like that you included some less known historical information and explained the influence it plays in modern medicine today.. Also I agree it would be something worth looking into I would love to see the outcome. I do think Astrology, like other factors plays a bigger role in our lives, than what we allow ourselves to believe and not for any specific reason. It just seems that there’s been several times through out history where we thought we had things all figured out, and years down the road we find out new information that proves us to be completely wrong and throws us back to square 1 or draws us too another conclusion. Just because one idea seems too be the most logical, that doesn’t deem it as set in stone. Overall I thought this to be A great article. Nice work.
I’m incredibly late to this article, but it’s exactly what I was looking for. I know that horoscopes are mainly just entertainment-only but a few weeks ago, I started reading mine for fun and actually found it helpful. Knowing it isn’t backed by science, I wanted to know more about what draws us to them and why the seem so accurate for some folks. Thank you!
We are (were) a joint family of 13 people since the beginning, My family was happily living together and everything was very much fine, In Feb I saw my horoscope and it said that there will be a sudden change in family structures and we will leave our house and it will be an undesired rellocation for me from between 23 March to 12 April. I laughed it out since there was nothing near to breaking up as a family In weeks our family issues started, It went worse every passing day and on 2nd April that is two days before writing this comment we seperated and now I am in a new house. Idk I am sad that we not living with our cousins now but this incident has shocked me that how accurately it predicted everything.
in 2010 i wanted to find out what time i was born so i made a chart and tried different times and accidentally memorized all the stuff i read. i wouldnt say i “believe” in astrology but ive done a lot of peoples charts for them to usually really positive review. then when i went back to school i took a lot of poetry classes and i did really well. i think studying astrology just tangible a lot of the things we feel about each other and also showed me how these things interact coexist and oppose one another. like virgo means ____, it could be a lot of things but if there is ___ in the chart then you would stress __ about virgo. likewise, if a poet says “i am unprincipled like a tiger” (chelsey minnis) while some people might have a more immediate visceral understanding of that statement, for me i needed some human fundamentals spelled out for me first. in short, i would highly recommend studying astrology to anyone who was raised by people with little to no empathy 😆
Astrology predicted that there is a 5% higher chance to get schizophrenia when one was born in winter? Don’t think so. Astrology makes some very weird claims and simply biases decisions. I have seen a couple split because she had such a strong belief in what an astrologist told her. Too me this all looked like a self fullfilling prophecy. I know the astrologist who caused this. A lovely person, but she couldn’t even predict her breakfast.
My sister was born 3 months early, in November instead of February. She relates more to Pisces than to Scorpio, so I think it has more to do with conception than birth. Especially, since doctors now commonly induce mothers whenever they think it’s best, rather than when their bodies are naturally ready. It’s wise to take everything with a grain of salt, but there are definitely some strong implications that people on in certain months act very similarly
Sorry, but these people need psychologists. Superstitious star speak is very unwise to help people with. We already have the languages needed to communicate deeply and emotionally. What the followers of astrology need to realize, is that it was never intended to be used in this way. Case in point, it’s still based on the Earth being the center of the universe. We have advanced well beyond that point, and really should get past all these failed religions.
I have not had good experience with astrology. I have known several people who hide behind “traits” of their sign and live by what is described versus just being who they are. To say the least, it’s annoying. It’s one thing to have faith or belief in something but I feel it’s another thing when you allow something to mold who you are and how you act just because of a label given (Leos, for example: in my experience love using astrology references to excuse maladaptive behavior many times in the past, on a daily basis). My ex constantly stated that he was “this way” because of some BS he read about his astrological sign. I have never cared to make more sense of it until now when I saw this article. After perusal the article, I still feel the same.
I have respect for anyone who does not believe but I had known effects and personality traits I noticed before I ever looked into my astrology. I was a completely different from a lot of my friends and never knew why. Intuition led me to Astrology and it went down into specifics and little subtle things I have ALWAYS done unconsciously but wasn’t completely aware of. This wasn’t just my sun sign which What people who are ignorant to astrology think, but down to all of the specific houses and each planetary placement in my chart. The same with crystals, I get the full effect before I even know when the stone does or means. Could just be in our DNA. Nevertheless, there is a truth behind it all, why do you think the past civilizations used it? They had a deep understanding of our roots and the cosmos. The ones who did magically vanished? Or were wiped out because they were too advanced and the rest of the world was too far behind.
I mean… “astrologers used to write things down” and “doctors write things down” is a pretty tenuous link. I totally accept that the time of year you’re born can affect things about your life. The simplest example is late December-Early January people lose their birthday in the chaos of Christmas and get a bit of a chip on their shoulder. But this effect can change depending on when and where you live (ie what major celebrations exist on your calendar)
I love astrology but I definitely use it as a spiritual practice for meditation and just delving deeper into my own personality. I think learning it is really interesting. And it’s way more complicated than sun signs which I wished this article would have explained. But still I also believe it’s not a science. Spirituality doesnt need to be explained or to have proof as long as it holds value to the one believing it.
2 out of 3? points(arguments) against astrology are just SOOOO nonsense…. (probably as the astrology itself). First of all – “astrologists lost by choosing geocentric model”. No, they didn’t, from human perspective that absolutely doesn’t matter if sun revolves around earth or earth around sun. Relativity! You know Einstein and stuff… Even astronomers do not make stelar maps how they would look from the sun, or even from the middle of the universe, but from the viewer perspective (geocentric). Second – “Newton found laws of physics and how planets interacts with each other” – OMG, that just proves that all planets and especially sun/moon has an actual impact on our lives, as we are affected by the gravity forces 🙂
“Think” – The only modern way to comprehend Astrology – is to go to the recorded history of Ancient Vedic. (Not a subject of Vedic vs Western – rather authentication of the foundation of Astrology) Sumer – had Astrology – The Universe works in synchronization Get to the subject – before yyou go to the zodiac. Religions have created propaganda around Astrology. Eventually – Physics will explain Astrology – in its foundation – not modern limited applications. You guys aren’t even addressing the Astrology – foundation – 17th century – by then had lost the Ancient Knowledge.
People who don’t believe in it haven’t studied it. I never thought about astrology before age 25, but l remember reading a description of my sign for my birthday in my teens and it was spot on. And it wasn’t the Barnum effect because l compared it to my family and friends and we all agreed it was common knowledge that l was the sporty type, and headstrong, full-on, « jump ahead first and ask questions later »…l’d always been like that. From age 25 l studied over 20’000 people. It’s easy to see in people. I can name some examples. Aries, the independent, honest but brutal type, Marlon Brando, Russel Crowe, ‘Negan’, Downey Jr. Opposite them Is Libra, the gentleman, always pleasant and delicate, Will Smith, Hugh Jackman, Jason Alexander. You can keep studying people and see that it works every time. There are 9 planets in a chart. I guess 3 to 4 signs when l meet someone or notice a celebrity for the first time. That’s one chance in 1000 or 2000. It’s completely the opposite of random chance.
Technically a retrograde is an astronomy term, not astrology. If planets outside of our solar system can affect weather here on Earth, then it’s totally plausible. Plus can’t call newspaper horoscopes astrology, at least have to start with a specific birth chart to you before you can make a decision.
I honestly find astrology useful as a Gemini in a relationship with a Scorpio it was very difficult to understand this person that I lived with in the way that they think in their thought process and how they deal with stress and not to hit the ticking point. Once I began to do a lot of research about the Scorpio personality how they deal with stress how their mind works and how they are compatible with a Gemini like me and what are our strong points and weak points it really has better than our relationship our communication has gotten way better than it used to although he does not believe in astrology and think it’s stupid I really took the time to do a lot of research so that I can compromise from my end and understand him instead of getting frustrated because I couldn’t get him or his ways of thinking’s in certain situations. Many and all the Scorpio personality traits wereaccurate to him and many of the Gemini personality traits were accurate To my actual personality.
So basically astrology has no logic, the behaviour of a person depends on the season he was born which is also one of the factors that affect a person’s behaviour. But why should one relate this with a solar calendar? Like people born from jan to march will have a particular behaviour, which makes sense. Only in some parts of world not everywhere, seasons are different around the world at same time.winter in the USA in December is actually summer in Australia. To conclude In general behaviour depends on season and not on any month of the year
My issue though is that people take astrology WAY too seriously. Don’t get me wrong I follow it. But people get to caught up in the hype. As human’s we’re quite complex creatures. You can’t brandish the complexities of being human under a single star or star signs of other planets moons. I’m an Aires. Someone told me because I am I’m going to be quite possessive in relationships. I’m thinking, dude you have no idea of who I am. And that’s my problem, people act like having a star sign/birth chart (when they don’t even know you) 100% determines what the relationship will be like. And it’s ignorant.
The only thing Astrology does right is explaining basic personalities and personality traits. When someone is born has no bearing whatsoever on their actual personality. And even then, people of one personality type are so vastly different. You can’t truly categorize human beings. The mind is so complex and convoluted that it would be impossible to pin any personality type on anyone.
When D grade astrophysicists forget to do their homework, I do it for them. You are very welcome ” “Abstract—Shawn Carlson’s 1985 study, published in Nature, which ended with a devastating verdict of astrology, is scrutinized. 1- The design of Carlson’s study violated the demands of fairness and its mode of analysis ignored common norms of statistics. 2- The study’s piecemeal analysis of sub-samples avoided testing the totals for astrological effects, as did the neglect of test power, effect size, and sample size. 3- Nevertheless, a correct reanalysis of Carlson’s two astrological tests reveals that astrologers matched profiles of the California Personality Inventory to natal charts better than expected by chance with marginal significance (threeway forced choice, p = .054), and that a positive result was replicable by a different assessment method (10-point rating, p = .04). 4- The results are regarded as insufficient to deem astrology as empirically verified, but they are sufficient to regard Carlson’s negative verdict on astrology as untenable”
My friend and I are OBSESSED with Astrology,we talk about it A LOT at school and eventually a lot of people found it REALLY interesting. Astrology isn’t a (S)*,it’s amazing! My sign is a Leo and I’m proud of it and so is one of my friends, we learn more about our Signs and realize our personalities more.
Another thing that a lot of people don’t understand is that just because u are born in a certain time frame doesn’t mean u will have every trait of that sign. Depending on where the other planets and stars are aligned also impacts fate and traits. Like I was born an Aries but due to where other planets were located I have very little Aries too me. It explains why I have so many Virgo and Sagg traits
As the most hardcore atheist you can ever meet (but it is my conviction we’re all immortal spiritual beings, older than the physical universe itself), I do think there is some hint that the choice, although coerced, of where, and when we inhabit a flesh body, is given to us, left to our own devices, so we DO have some saying in the matter.
That’s why Indian astrology is much powerful and relevant as compared to non Indian astrology. Indian astrology studies your sun sign and moon sign on the Basis of your moon and sun rising or at the time of dawn. The timing of your birth dictates important events that will happen in your life because it tells the degree of sun and other planets in future.
I look at astrology as being more related to the seasons and what age you are at certain times of typical exposure and experiences throughout a year have general effects on your personality. Leo for example typically seen as extroverted and sociable would have been almost 1 years old when they experienced their first summer (a very social and outdoors season) what general effects might this have on personality development if at the cusp of developing language and observation skills you are in the most social outdoorsy season (in the northern hemisphere at least) that’s just my idea on it.
Astrology is absolutely a science. Astrology was born out of the science of astronomy. Astrology is misrepresented by daily horoscopes based only on the Sun sign sometimes other planets superficially. If you are born under the Sun in Virgo with your Mercury in Libra you’re going to think like a Libra not a Virgo making you think you’re not a Virgo.
i am a beginner astrologist myself and i personally believe that people are not a zodiac sign. a zodiac sign does not define you. neither does a birth chart. your life expierence defines you. also horoscopes. i dont believe that they say what will happen, i believe that making choices in certain astrological situations gives a better outcome. that is why i try to write my horoscopes for me by myself. but with the personality thing, i believe that birth charts can give you an insight to the base of your personality. the rest is defined by genes, life experience, etc. you are not a sun sign. you have a sun sign.
Astrology is scientific, a little example which will make you understand why, moon pulls tides and waves on earth which is almost all water and guess whats 70% water? You! So the moon even has a pull on you and when its moon related events like moon getting closer or farther on those days tempered people will get more angry and its all science
SCIENTIFICALLY ACCURATE HOROSCOPE ♈ Aries: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from seasonal affective disorder, alcohol abuse, autism, and/or bipolar disorder. ♉ Taurus: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from alcohol abuse and/or autism. ♊ Gemini: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from alcohol abuse, autism, and/or down syndrome. ♋ Cancer: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from alcohol abuse, autism, and/or down syndrome. ♌ Leo: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from autism, and/or down syndrome. ♍ Virgo: You are more likely to suffer from an allergy to milk and eggs. ♎ Libra: You are more likely to suffer from an allergy to milk and eggs. ♏ Scorpio: You are more likely to suffer from an allergy to milk and eggs. ♐ Sagittarius: Nothing yet. I haven’t yet had the opportunity to develop this further. Are you interested in helping me? Thanks in advance! ♑ Capricorn: You are more likely to suffer from schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder, recurrent depressive disorder, and/or bipolar disorder. ♒ Aquarius: You are more likely to suffer from schizophrenia and/or bipolar disorder. ♓ Pisces: You are more likely to have an optimistic outlook. You are more likely to suffer from schizophrenia, seasonal affective disorder, alcohol abuse, autism, and/or bipolar disorder.
I believe in astrology because I believe it’s the study of synchronicities between patterns of energy in various forms or scales. That in and of itself is sort of a “science” but the philosophical/social/political/metaphysical aspects of astrology are much more interpretive and placed on top of the more scientific elements. Astrology isn’t itself a science, but incorporates a lot of science, but then focuses on how the physical science synchronizes with the unfolding of all the aspects of our lives to find MEANING in the science. That’s the part that science is unconcerned with, nor should it be concerned with it. Science is about the cold hard facts, and that’s how it should be. Astrology is astronomy and physics… with interpretive meaning applied on top of it. And to me… that’s just more interesting most of the time, and gets into the psychology of humanity (itself a soft science that astrology incorporates) and how it correlates with the physics of the universe in noticeable patterns of unfolding energy. It’s a cycle, which is what the zodiac represents. Everything in the unvierse moves in cyclical patterns, and that pattern is always able to be correlated to the zodiac in how the energy forms as it progresses through that cycle. “Energy” refers to everything from light, radiation, magnetism, gravity, etc… to calories, watts, momentum, the energy of the ground holding you up, the energy of you going about your day, the energy of love, the energy of hate, the energy of fast things, the energy of slow things, the energy of small things, the energy of big things.
Hear me out, if humans were to believe the existence of something like “human” could be possible to exist I bet you would ask for scientific explanation. How do we have emotions? How did any of this come to picture? How is this all true? There must be some truth about God and astrology. But I don’t agree with people taking it too seriously like tf stop being cringe
It could be a classification. To me it’s pretty obvious, if mass is energy, we’re mass, we’re energy, and at the moment I was born the energy was pulsing, existed in a certain way, position, structure of space time continuum. I presume I had to be a part of all that space time continuum and energy balance at the time I was born. Maybe it’s in us to know astrology is pretty accurate when do e right.
Guys i wanna lightened this situation with my experience in astrology. I become interested in astrology since my friends talk so much bout it. First, i learned my Sun sign after that moon and rising sign etc. Then i look at my birth chart and i read all the information bout it. Guess what. Its bullshit. It says bc the hard position of Pluto u may have problems with ur dad and all men. I don’t have any problems with my dad. Also it says partnership is so important in ur lifetime u can’t do without partner etc. But it also says; (in north nodes purpose) U should learn ur self worth, in ur past life u learn others. So partnership is not important for this life time blah blah. Yeah it makes no sense. If ur smart u don’t believe this.
What I don’t like about astrology is that it boxes you. Sometimes you fool yourself to fit in that box just because that is what your natal chart says. It believes that the cosmos has control over us and it dictates what you can be and cannot be. I dislike how it believes we can write our own fate and instead we just live what the cosmos has already written based on our time, date and place of birth.
Astrology itself does shit about your personality, but it still helps people the same way that homeopathy did back then: its an easy way to reassure yourself and boost morale. But if you actually try to act a certain way because of your zodiac sign, it’ll be the same as hoping that Homeopathic medicines will ACTUALLY cure a terminal illness.
But astrology wasn’t ment to be cool It’s ment as a tool And so far this tool can’t be explained by scientists,people add there own ideology to it. Where as you can’t because it’s true and always need proof …. But i agree with the months we were born in have alot to do with our character and behavior
I don’t think astrology is real. This doesn’t mean that I think weather/seasons that your mother carried you in can’t have an impact on your personality, but I just have a really hard time believing that I’m a Taurus because I don’t fit it at all. Taurus descriptions are almost the exact opposite of me. They mentioned in the article that people born in March and April (like me) get Seasonal Affective Disorder more. I’m sure that is true, but I am also a Taurus. How does me getting Seasonal Affective Disorder more prove that I am a Taurus? It doesn’t. One actually has science backing it up and the other is a bunch of nonsense. There is nothing that annoys me more than people who make judgements about you before they know you based solely on your astrology sign. ie. a girl won’t date me cause I’m a taurus and she has bad experiences with taurus’ or her ex is a taurus. 🙄Personally I think it is doing more harm than good, but I can’t keep people from believing what they want. I think that MBTI despite being a “pseudoscience” like astrology, there is much more validity to it. (I’m an ENTP and that seems to mostly fit) I still think that people should get to know people first before judging them on there type though. I won’t stop being friends with someone or stop dating someone because they test as a XXXX.
ANYONE WHO DOESNT BELIEVE IN ASTROLOGY, PLEASE DO YOUR BIRTH CHART. it will make u a believer. I did mine, and it was spot on. I had to look for my birth certificate tho because I wanted to know the exact time i was born. After doing it, I did my boyfriends (he keeps his birth certificate in a safe place) and OMG his had me shaking. It called out everything I knew about him (been together 5 years) and it explained everything I could never understand.
Forgive me for what I’m about to say. If this offends you, you are welcome to comment and defend your Claim. So If it’s based by Personalized prediction’s therefore it isn’t real nor True. Here’s the problem with people who believe this, You can’t just depend on you’re horoscope for your own personal gain. if you just depend on that your just faking you identity. Change My mind
Hahahaha people wish to believe that their is anything that could tell them future so they less stress or protect their self previously of what future carries, sorry but tge plain pure truth is tgat only God the creator knows tge future of people and if a human can stop a danger or seize a gain due to seeing a future God would have show it to human, people dont need to see a future they need to clean their inners to feel peace and not to fear .
I think astrology is important, when contemplating a relationship. It is important,. not only to be spiritually comparable, but astrologically comparable. I think sidereal, is the most accurate. Not everybody, is their tropical sign. Jupiter, for instance represents the man in a woman’s chart, venus represents the woman in a man’s chart. Just an example Vedic, is the same, as sidereal. Tropical, is seasonal, usefully for planting, & harvesting.
Hilarious title! Astrology is DEFINITE an esoteric science! It’s based on recurring patterns and observations. It can and has been tested (think Carl Jung’s archetypes.); it’s definitely more real than most think. Horoscopes on the other hand, as found in most newspapers and magazines, are simply entertainment.
People using zodiac signs is lowest part or you can say least important part of astrology. Astrology is fully developed science and it reached its peak in Indian subcontinent only, many other civilization have also worked upon it, but today even in India astrologers are just using this for earning money. Astrology shows influence of cosmos on human body, so it’s covers all the things to be arrenged in such a way that it will be helpful for human beings in reaching its ultimate goal. And by the way we are microcosmos. 🙏
I want to understand why people believe it, that’s why I come here searching for points. Have you got any good points people so that I could understand your perspective as well coz rn I believe this is horse shit. Is it about having faith or belief in something but it doesn’t sound like a thing you could just have faith in.
I am new to astrology there is much I don’t know however I do know that the ancient people of earth had a better grasp of astrology than we do today and I’m talking about B.C. ancient not A.D. ancient. Just look at the buildings they have created we cannot accomplish what they could back then. Their rock cutting and carving tech is far better than what we could do today. I also believe they were wiser than we are and that modern civilizations have come to pass in the distant past. We humans have existed longer than what we are being told. Now thats an opinion however the builder of the Great Pyramid were smart enough and wise enough to build a structure that would survive time and they build the pyramid to the exact dimensions as our earth if scaled by 432,000 times there are just way to many coincidences to chock it up to just random circumstance.
In regards to the medical stuff I am 99% sure that is true. I am taurus and every single person that I know that is one has issues or had had issues with tonsilloliths and taurus does rule over this area. As well many will have very traumatic experience as children such as losing a parent in one away or another 😢.