Astrology may have some influence on consciousness and psi, but these influences are not strong or very rare. A meta-analysis of over forty controlled studies suggests that astrologers are unable to perform significantly better than chance even on basic tasks such as predicting astrology to ordinary consciousness. Instead, they suggest its relevance to altered consciousness.
Kelly’s argument covers four stages: 1) Trace the consciousness responsible for the astrological experience; 2) Determine whether the experience is “something unusual”. Many astrologers attribute a successful birth-chart reading to intuition or psychic ability, where the birth chart acts like a crystal ball. They relate this to shamanism, where they relate astrology to transcendent realities.
The possibility that astrology might be relevant to consciousness and psi is not denied, but such influences would seem to be very weak or very rare. The appeal to “practical experiment” or experience is not as straightforward as it may seem. Recent or previously missed studies have not changed the conclusion that the performance of astrologers has no useful implications for consciousness and psi.
A large-scale test of persons born less than five minutes apart found no hint of the similarities predicted by astrology. The authors argue that the astrological experience is more likely to work by “hidden persuaders” than by either objective or psychic criteria. Astrology has been rejected by the scientific community as having no explanatory power for describing the universe, and scientific testing has found no evidence to support this claim.
📹 InPresence 0075: Why Astrology Endures
InPresence host, Jeffrey Mishlove, PhD, is author of The Roots of Consciousness, Psi Development Systems, and The PK Man.
Is there any connection between astrology and psychology?
Psychological astrology is a branch of psychology that combines the study of mental status, thoughts, emotions, and tendencies with the study of celestial positions at birth. It focuses on the 12 zodiac signs, each associated with distinct traits, which are believed to influence an individual’s personality uniquely. Houses, represented by zodiac signs, are grouped into different life areas, such as wealth, assets, material prosperity, relationships, and marriage. These houses provide insights into an individual’s personality and the influence of celestial positions on their mental makeup.
Did Einstein believe astrology?
Einstein’s sole known commentary on astrology is a 1943 epistle to Eugene Simon, wherein he concurs with Simon regarding the pseudoscientific nature of astrology, emphasizing its resilience and longevity over centuries.
Is astrology related to spirituality?
The practice of astrology is not solely confined to the interpretation of horoscopes; it is also intertwined with spiritual beliefs in numerous religious traditions. Individuals utilize astrology as a means of attaining a more profound comprehension of existence and spiritual advancement. In Hinduism, astrology is utilized as a tool for self-discovery and the attainment of true happiness. This is achieved by examining one’s astrological chart, which is believed to facilitate the breaking free from the illusions of life.
What did Carl Jung say about astrology?
Astrology, according to Jung, is a psychological description of character, with planets representing individual character components. The horoscope is considered the chronometric equivalent of individual character, and a person’s natal chart can provide insights into their soul’s plan for their incarnation. By comparing the movement of planets through the year to one’s natal chart, he found that transits provide a meaningful coincidence of planetary aspects and positions with the character or existing psychic state of the questioner.
These insights can be for short temporal frames (months or years) or for longer millennial time frames (eons). Jung was dubbed the “father of the New Age” for his idea of how the collective psyche of the human race changes with the end of one Platonic month and the beginning of another. As a medical doctor, Jung felt obligated to alert people to the nature of our time and the major cosmic transformation as the age of Pisces transitions to the age of Aquarius.
Did Sigmund Freud use astrology?
The individual did not consider thought transference to be a superior explanation for prophecy in comparison to astrology, given that both were classified as occult. However, he did postulate that it could offer a more plausible account for the remarkable degree of precision observed in the forecasts.
What did Muhammad say about astrology?
The Hadith, a collection of Islamic religious teachings, is a significant part of the Islamic faith. It outlines the instructions and practices of Muhammad, who criticized the legality and illegality of astrology. According to Abu Dawud, seeking knowledge from the stars is considered witchcraft, which is inherently forbidden in Islam. The Hadith also emphasizes that rain is a blessing bestowed only by Allah, and any belief that rain is a result of other beings is considered disbelief.
The Hadith also mentions the stars, stating that those who suggest rain originates from a star are considered disbelievers in Allah. This concept of astrology and the belief in celestial beings’ influence on anything other than what is enshrined in the Quran and Hadith constitutes shirk (blasphemy) and leads one to leave the fold of the religion.
Second-century Islamic scholar Imam Ali, the fourth caliph of Islam and cousin and son-in-law of Muhammad, views astrology as fundamentally forbidden in the Islamic religion. He warns followers not to learn the science of stars except for guidance on land or sea, as it leads to divining and an astrologer is a diviner. This aligns with the Quran, which points to stars and astrology as only a means of navigation.
However, prominent scholars like Ibn Arabi and Ikhwan argue that planets are not considered God but do suggest each prophet with a specific planet/celestial being. Prophet Idris, also known as Enoch, was gifted with great knowledge of the stars and used his gift to meditate upon God’s grandeur and teach others. He believed that the stars and moon contributed to mankind and founded the study of the stars.
Different sects of Islam offer varying perspectives on the concept of astrology.
Do physicists believe in astrology?
Astrology is a belief system that suggests a connection between astronomical phenomena and human events or personality descriptions. However, it has been criticized by the scientific community for lacking explanatory power and lack of scientific validity. Scientific testing has found no evidence to support the premises or effects outlined in astrological traditions. The most famous test, led by Shawn Carlson, concluded that natal astrology performed no better than chance.
Astrology has not demonstrated its effectiveness in controlled studies and has no scientific validity, making it regarded as pseudoscience. There is no proposed mechanism by which stars and planets affect people and events on Earth in the way astrologers claim, which contradicts well-understood aspects of biology and physics.
What psychological effect is astrology?
The Barnum effect is a phenomenon where people believe that horoscopes are meant for them, leading them to find parallels between the text and their own lives. This effect is common in “New Age” professions like tarot card readers, magicians, and psychics. However, the Barnum effect can be dangerous when it interferes with decision-making. Trusting vague predictions can prevent us from logically analyzing our options and choosing the best outcome.
For example, if we refuse to date someone based on their zodiac sign or if our horoscope predicts tragedy, we may be influenced by the predictions. If we trust these predictions too much, they can change the course of our lives by steering us away from the best decisions.
What did Aristotle say about astrology?
Aristotle’s beliefs indicate that celestial phenomena not only regulate seasonal cycles but also influence animal behavior and lifespan. Additionally, he postulated that the position of the sun may exert a profound impact on the processes of generation and destruction.
Who is God in metaphysics?
The concept of God can be situated within the field of metaphysics as a being that posits perfection and occupies a primary position within the hierarchy of perfection. In addition, it is the subject of theological discourse.
Did Isaac Newton believe in astrology?
Newton’s astrological contributions were largely overlooked in both manuscript and print, with Derek Whiteside failing to identify any references to horoscopes in his 50 million words of mathematical manuscripts in 1977. This dearth of interest in astrology represents a significant challenge within the field of astrology.
📹 The Problem With Astrology | Deep Dive
In the past couple years I’ve started to question my beliefs much more critically which has made me interested in looking at my …
Anna, i started perusal this article at 3am…and ohh girl did you keep me awake!! You’re wittiness and dedication is really impressive, taking to account you did all this work without the promise of large monetary gain, fame or popularity. I can see it in you´re eyes that you did this for the sole sake of self-development whilst taking the opportunity to convey it as unbiased as possible to you´re “followers” and the public in general. It was very soothing, informative and i’m sure you have positively thwarted many conceited fables. I just feel the need to say that, you mixed the words “believe” and “know” many times. For example at 5:33 and 1:35:13 (to name a few) but at 1:28:13 (to name one) you use it correctly. To put it in perspective, a blind person believes in the sun while someone who isn´t, SEES it and thus “knows” it, implying the unnecessary use of a belief. Also, when you say that you´re an atheist you´re not really putting yourself in a better position. Both theists and atheists share the common conduct of reasoning in wich both believe in something wich has little or no empirical evidence. Believing in a “god” or not believing in a “god” implicitly revolves around the same thing. Anyone can believe anything they want whether true or not, the point though, is to “know” as accurately and precisely as possible for the sole purpose of our individual/collective wordly desires and benefits. The English language has many barriers and self-contradictions and our syntax can be very misleading or deviating depending on the context of our intentions based on the circumstances.
this website deserves more recognition. personally, i have never related to my sun sign (Aquarius) when i was younger, and i do relate to it now a little more now, however, that is only through one source of information on astrology and there are plenty of definitions of Aq that do not apply. (certainly i could try to see if it is influenced by my moon or whatever, but i’m not going to cling on pluto if it gives me relatable description). furthermore, i looked into birth charts of my siblings that i know place and time of birth of, and it was so off in some places. i think i’ll stick to genetics and environment before constellations and planets positions.
I have always been interested in observing people & making deductions. Not just random deductions, but deductions which can be explained from people’s body language, behaviour & such stuff. I’m good at reading people and am interested in a variety of topics. The problem of cognitive bias always worried me, way before I knew anything about zodiac. My interest in astrology is more in the philosophical aspect of signs, rather than tOdaY’S fOrECaSt sort of stuff. So I studied the philosophy associated with each of the 12 signs & how it’s a progression. Fascinating stuff. Reading people’s behaviour & accurately getting a decent idea about their personality wasn’t a problem for me by this time. So I made it more difficult for myself, I started deducing their dominant zodiac placements. Decoding people based on their actions, body language, behaviour is something I cannot stop, it’s like a reflex which I can’t help. So a MAJORITY of people I tried to guess the zodiac placements of were & are strangers. Could be people I meet in-person, could be random people I watch online or on tv, could be historical figures I randomly come across while reading or perusal or listening to something(usually accompanied with some description about those historical figures or something about their actions, what they did etc). Never do I check the birth details in advance, because what’s the point of it then…and it’s no fun. My conclusions or ‘guesses’ are most of the times 1-3 signs. My accuracy rate is 70%.
I don’t “believe” in astrology the way I believe in facts/logic, but I still love it. I think it’s because I like mythology and symbolism. My favorite part is trying to figure out where the planets are in the sky and what they are doing, and learning about the constellations. The signs are interesting to me because they connect to the seasons (but it varies on the culture and time period). I don’t use it for predictions, planning or for defining things or people. How could you? There are so many systems and interpretations – all think they are right.
I’m only 11 minutes in but I really appreciate you including logical fallacies and an explanation of valid and sound arguments! I got my degree in philosophy and soooo many people in life and online told me it’s useless because you can’t get a job and we already know everything. Philosophy helped me in a much more meaningful way by making me a strong critical thinker and protecting me from misinformation. It makes me sad and frustrated to hear people disregard the philosophy because there is so much misinformation out there that could be avoided and straight up prevented with it. I find that lots of people take the word “philosophy” a bit too loosely and think that it means exploring ideas that are more in line with pseudoscience when really philosophy is trying to combat that stuff. I wouldn’t change anything about my degree because it’s helped me so much and I did still end up getting a job that I wanted.
I remember this incident when I looked up my birth chart and predictions about my life. There was alot of shit but the following points are the only ones I remember It said that I will always crave for love and approval from my mom and will never get it. That will make me miserable. It also said that I have some fault in my birth chart that will affect my health and eyesight. I won’t be very successful.Yes I am a very sickly person everyday I am scared that I will die cause of my health issues. My eyesight is very poor as well. But the thing is when I read the mom part I just started crying it hurt me so much because it is true. All this shit affected me mentally so much. Before that I just lived freely you know if I was sick I would still smile and be happy because I am an optimistic person. I get sad for a min and next min forget all about it. That day I was so miserable feeling like a burden to everyone. I have stopped reading horoscope or birth charts after that. I don’t care but this shit is harmful and will effect you negatively. You will start doubting yourself. It will affect your decisions. It is basically manipulation. It doesn’t matter what happens okay just live let it be. Be grateful keep moving. Love God bless