Reasons Why Vedic Astrology Is Unreliable?

Vedic astrology is considered more accurate than Western astrology due to its unique astrological signs and the concept of karma. Vedic astrology adjusts the signs for precession, while Western astrology keeps every sign fixed at fixed times of year. However, this does not mean that Western astrology isn’t real.

Vedic astrology is rooted in ancient Hindu tradition and is considered significant by its followers. It uses modern astronomy to understand astronomical phenomena within the system and has remained intact for thousands of years. Vedic astrology uses the accurate sidereal zodiac, which keeps track of the locations of all planets. While some people believe that this makes it more accurate, it is not a personality quiz or armchair psychoanalysis.

Both Vedic and Western astrology are accurate, with Vedic being very old (approximately 5000 years old) and having many eminent personalities of medieval history like Kalidas and Varaha Mihir. Vedic astrology takes precession into account and calculates horoscopes based on the updated ecliptic path. Western astrology, however, is more accurate due to its use of modern astronomy and the concept of karma.

In conclusion, Vedic astrology is considered more accurate than Western astrology due to its unique astrological signs, the concept of karma, and its ability to adapt to precession. Both astrologies have their merits and drawbacks, but both offer valuable insights into life through spirit and intention.

Why are my signs different in Vedic astrology?

The Vedic system uses the sidereal zodiac, which is the starting point for measuring the positions of planets and stars. People who know their natal chart in Western astrology are often shocked when their planets or ascendant are suddenly in a different sign in the Vedic system. This tendency is so strong that the author doesn’t always mention the names of the signs when giving a Vedic reading, especially if the Sun, Moon, or ascendant have changed.

Instead, the author focuses on what can be seen in the person’s chart and what it means for their lives. When asked about the signs, the author mentions if something has changed significantly and reassures them that it’s not that big of a deal.

Should I trust Vedic or Western astrology?

Vedic astrology, also known as Hindu astrology, is a more complex and less fixed system compared to western astrology. It is less generic and involves more moving pieces, making it less accurate than western readings. Vedic astrology, which has its roots in Babylonian and Hellenistic tradition, uses the sidereal zodiac and assigns houses based on birthdays, sun signs, and location. It has 12 signs and uses earth to gauge an individual’s birth perspective.

Western astrology, originating from the 2nd century BC, is based on Ptolemy’s Tetrabiblos and has roots in Babylonian and Hellenistic traditions. It assigns houses based on birthdays, sun signs, and location, with 12 signs. Vedic astrology, on the other hand, has its roots in an ancient Indian text and dates back to around 10, 000 BC. The Sanskrit name for Vedic astrology is Jyotisa or Jyotish, which can translate into a heavenly body.

Vedic astrology is believed to be closely tied to spirituality and was born from sages and seers and the Four Vedas, which are centered around mantras, rituals, philosophy, and divine revelations. While western astrology uses the tropical zodiac, Vedic astrology is more concerned with the physical placement of constellations and applies the sidereal zodiac.

Which is accurate Vedic or Western astrology?

Vedic astrology is superior to Western astrology due to its distinctive dasha system, which is based on Nakshatras, and allows for more precise forecasting of future occurrences.

Is astrology true according to Vedas?

Astrology, originally known as jyotish or “the science of light”, is a method used to understand a person’s karma by analyzing the positions of planets and stars. It is considered the “eye of the Vedas” and is used to provide guidance to individuals who feel lost or confused on their life’s journey. Astrology is also known as the “science of fate” and is used to understand various aspects of life, including future success in endeavors like marriage, moving into a new home, or business ventures. In the past, astrology was even used to predict war outcomes or governmental decisions, leading rulers to hire astrologers for better guidance.

How accurate are Vedic astrologers?

In this article, Won, an astrologer, addresses the ongoing debate surrounding the precision of Vedic astrology in comparison to Western astrology. She asserts that Vedic astrology’s time calculations are more precise than those of Western astrology, and that the use of divisional charts and timing analysis is more detailed and accurate. Additionally, Won underscores the precision of the dasha timing system as a means of elucidating the nuances of personal timing and forecasting.

Which form of astrology is most accurate?

Nādi Astrology is a detailed and accurate method of predicting the future based on the combined results of all sixteen divisional charts. However, it requires precise birth time and knowledge of genuine Nādi texts, which are often unpublished and kept secret by custodians. This is similar to Samhitā texts in north India, such as Bhrigu Samhitā or Rāvana Samhitā. Atma, the’real’ self, is immortal and characterizes the real self. It changes only to the physical bodies during common stages such as birth, childhood, teenage, adulthood, old age, and death.

Atma enters a different body based on one’s Karma and takes form based on their good or bad deeds. In Karmic terms, a transition like this is like a person being promoted or demoted based on their sincerely, honest, and efficient work in an organization.

Can you trust Vedic astrology?

Astrology is considered pseudoscience due to its lack of scientific validity and effectiveness in controlled studies. There is no proposed mechanism for how stars and planets affect people and events on Earth, which contradicts well-understood aspects of biology and physics. Modern scientific inquiry focuses on the correlation between astrological traditions and seasonal birth in humans. Most professional astrologers rely on astrology-based personality tests and make predictions about the remunerator’s future.

Those who continue to believe in astrology are characterized as doing so despite the lack of verified scientific basis and strong evidence to the contrary. Astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson emphasized the importance of understanding how nature shapes the world around us, as without this knowledge, individuals can easily become victims of those seeking to take advantage of them.

What are the criticism of Vedic astrology?

Critics argue that Vedic Astrology lacks empirical evidence, as many astrological predictions are subjective, making it difficult to validate its accuracy. The precession of equinoxes, which shifts zodiac signs over time, challenges the accuracy of Vedic Astrology, which relies on the fixed tropical zodiac. Additionally, Vedic Astrology allows for multiple interpretations of birth charts, leading to inconsistencies in astrological readings, which critics argue undermines its credibility.

Can Vedic astrology be wrong?

Astrology has been criticized by the scientific community for lacking explanatory power for describing the universe. Scientific testing has been conducted, but no evidence has been found to support the premises or purported effects outlined in astrological traditions. Despite its status as a pseudoscience, astrology retains a position among the sciences in modern India. In 2001, India’s University Grants Commission and Ministry of Human Resource Development introduced “Jyotir Vigyan” or “Vedic astrology” as a discipline of study in Indian universities, stating that it allows for accurate predictions on time scale. This decision was backed by a 2001 judgement of the Andhra Pradesh High Court.

Despite widespread protests from the scientific community and Indian scientists working abroad, the Supreme Court dismissed a petition in 2004 that astrology was not a promotion of religion. In 2011, the Bombay High Court referred to the 2004 ruling when it dismissed a case challenging astrology’s status as a science. As of 2014, astrology continues to be taught at various universities in India, and there is a movement to establish a national Vedic University to teach astrology alongside the study of tantra, mantra, and yoga.

Why Vedic astrology is true?

Astrology, a long-standing scientific field, has been criticized for lacking clear evidence that stars and planets affect us. Astrology relies on stories and ideas that are difficult to prove with science, as it relies on guessing about patterns in the sky rather than conducting experiments. Additionally, astrology’s workings are based on old ideas about the universe, which have evolved over time. This has led to some astrologers’ predictions not aligning with current knowledge.

For example, the zodiac sign may not be accurate due to precession, which has caused stars to move since the first invention of astrology. Furthermore, astrology lacks a clear explanation for how stars and planets could affect us, with some astrologers suggesting it is due to the stars, but scientists argue these theories are too weak to have a significant impact on us.

What does Lord Krishna say about astrology?

The teachings of Lord Krishna as presented in the Bhagavad Gita are primarily concerned with spiritual teachings, the concept of duty, and the process of self-realization. However, it would be inaccurate to consider astrology to be a central theme within this context. Nevertheless, it would be beneficial to examine a variety of astrological perspectives.