In the world of magical spells, few people are aware of their existence, and Dumbledore is one of them. His overwhelming magical skill led to the Ministry’s attempts to hire him as their head of government, but he consistently refused all offers. Dumbledore was offered the Minister of Magic three times before Voldemort asked for a DADA teacher post. He didn’t know that at the time, but his insistence that he didn’t want power made him a hypocrite.
The wizarding world supported Albus Dumbledore for Minister when Bagnold retired, but Fudge was appointed when Dumbledore refused the office. Trelawney was kept on because Dumbledore didn’t want Voldemort or his followers to find out about the prophecy. However, Dumbledore had taken a different path, distancing himself from Grindelwald and becoming a respected teacher at Hogwarts. He had built up a reputation as a talented and talented individual.
The only reasonable explanation for Dumbledore’s refusal to accept the position is his insistence that he didn’t want power, even if it would help the wizarding world. Since the prophecy was made to Dumbledore regarding the Dark, he didn’t trust himself with power. If Dumbledore had been Minister for Magic, he wouldn’t have been able to work with Harry and gain his trust. The British Wizarding World would be different if Dumbledore had acquiesced to public demand and taken the position after Minister Bagnold retired.
Towards the end of Deathly Hallows, Dumbledore reveals that he refused the post of Minister for Magic on several occasions due to his insistence that power would be too great a temptation.
📹 THE TRUTH || The Real Reason Why Dumbledore Didn’t Become Minister Of Magic
Please watch: “The Life Of Marius de Romanus (Vampire Chronicles)” https://www.youtube.com/embed/MCQgGPNgzag …
Did Fudge know Sirius was innocent?
Following the battle at the Department of Mysteries, Dumbledore and Fudge engaged in a private discussion. The agenda included the return of Voldemort, Harry Potter’s innocence, public safety measures, and the veracity of Sirius Black’s culpability.
Why did Dumbledore refuse to be minister of magic?
The individual in question exhibited a profound distrust of their own capabilities, nearly taking over the world with Grindelwald. This was driven by a deep-seated fear of a repeat of the situation that had previously transpired, due to the pervasive corruption within the Ministry.
Why didn’t Fawkes save Dumbledore?
In the Harry Potter films, Fawkes was created by a mechanical machine, which Richard Harris, who played Dumbledore, thought was a real bird. Pottermore features a feature on Fawkes, and the fact that he sacrificed his life to save Dumbledore’s at the Battle of the Department of Mysteries, didn’t help him at the Battle of the Astronomy Tower, suggests he may have understood he was killed by his own orders. The Harry Potter Wiki has 161 images related to Fawkes.
Why didn’t Fudge believe Harry?
British wizard Cornelius Oswald Fudge, O. M. (First Class), served as the thirty-second Minister for Magic of the British Ministry of Magic from 1990 to 1996. He had complete control of the Ministry of Magic, the main governing body of the British wizarding world. Fudge began his career as Junior Minister in the Department of Magical Accidents and Catastrophes and succeeded Millicent Bagnold as Minister for Magic.
In the 1992-1993 school year, Fudge faced criticism for his proposal of a Muggle Protection Act, which was losing reputation due to Arthur Weasley’s possession of a Flying Ford Anglia. Ginny Weasley, controlled by the Riddle’s diary, started attacking Muggle-born students at Hogwarts School, using the basilisk concealed within the Chamber of Secrets. Fudge took Hogwarts gamekeeper Rubeus Hagrid to Azkaban for his alleged connection to the attacks.
In the 1993-1994 school year, Fudge faced the escape of assumed mass-murderer Sirius Black from Azkaban. He stationed Dementors at Hogwarts and Hogsmeade, but Black narrowly escaped from Fudge’s fingers.
Why did the Minister of Magic not believe Voldemort was back?
Voldemort’s fear and threat to wizarding Britain led Minister Fudge to deceive himself into believing that Dumbledore was trying to usurp his position as Minister for Magic. Fudge used his power within the Ministry and the Daily Prophet to make it look like Dumbledore and Potter were liars and “nutters”. He stripped Dumbledore of his titles and statuses, including Supreme Mugwump of the International Confederation of Wizards, Chief Warlock of the Wizengamot, Order of Merlin, and headmastership of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry.
Harry, who supported Dumbledore and claimed Voldemort returned, suffered from this campaign, making him a deluded attention-seeker. To further destabilize Dumbledore and Harry, Fudge planted his Senior Undersecretary Dolores Umbridge as the D. A. D. A. teacher at Hogwarts and later the Hogwarts High Inquisitor. He also made it clear that anyone siding with Dumbledore should clear out their desks in the Ministry’s office. The majority of the wizarding community ceased supporting Dumbledore and Harry, losing the chance to prepare themselves against Voldemort.
Was Dumbledore ever a Minister for Magic?
The Ministry of Magic, established in 1707, is a magical organization in Britain. It is democratically elected and has a maximum term of seven years. The Minister for Magic is responsible for all matters relating to the magical community in Britain and has sole jurisdiction over their Ministry. The Muggle Prime Minister has no role in appointing the Minister for Magic, whose election is a matter for the magical community themselves. Emergency visits to the Muggle Prime Minister by the Minister for Magic are announced by a portrait of Ulick Gamp, the first Minister for Magic.
No Muggle Prime Minister has ever entered the Ministry of Magic, as ex-Minister Dugald McPhail explains that their young minds couldn’t cope with it. The community generally supports the Minister for Magic, believing that they can manage themselves competently and avoid interference from the Muggles.
Why did Dumbledore stop hating muggles?
Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore explores the blood pact between Dumbledore and Grindelwald, focusing on their initial goal of wizards ruling over muggles. However, Dumbledore eventually grew to appreciate and respect muggles, leading him to abandon the cause. Dumbledore’s inclusion of muggle Jacob in his plans to combat Grindelwald signifies his growing respect for muggles and his trust in them in a fight against powerful magic. This change in perspective reflects his biggest mistake in the Harry Potter saga – allying himself with Grindelwald.
Having a muggle around Dumbledore changed his perspective on himself and the Wizarding World. Jacob, a newcomer to magic, experienced marvels and spells for the first time, even entering Hogwarts Castle. For Dumbledore, having a wide-eyed character allowed him to see magic from a different perspective and appreciate his own magical powers.
Dumbledore’s decision to put Jacob in dangerous situations involving Grindelwald showed his willingness to have faith in the most unlikely places. When he accompanied Jacob to the streets of Bhutan, his protective regard for Jacob and muggles was on display, resulting in Jacob suffering the Unforgivable Cruciatus Curse. This connection between Dumbledore and Jacob further demonstrates his connection with the type of person he once felt superior over.
Who was the best minister of magic?
The Harry Potter series has featured various Ministers for Magic, each with unique abilities and responsibilities. Cornelius Fudge, Faris Spavin, Rufus Scrimgeour, Millicent Bagnold, Hermione Granger, and Kingsley Shacklebolt are some of the most notable Ministers for Magic. Fudge’s early years were peaceful, but his later actions put students at risk. Shacklebolt, a member of The Order of the Phoenix, became one of the greatest Ministers for Magic, implementing reforms and eradicating favoritism.
The Minister for Magic is the highest-ranking position in the Ministry of Magic, making the individual the most important in the wizarding community in Britain. They chair the Wizengamot to pass laws and lead the nation during both peace and war. However, not all Ministers for Magic are created equally, and some may be more suited for the job than others.
Why did Dumbledore not want to be leader?
Dumbledore’s decision to turn down the Ministry was based on his fears of becoming a tyrant or dictator, a sentiment he may have grown past as a young man. Although he may have grown older and matured past this reaction, turning down the position was unnecessary. Dumbledore’s concern was not about minor issues, but becoming an all-powerful dictator. Many in the Wizarding World face discrimination, including prejudice against muggle born and werewolves, goblins, and half-giants like Hagrid. Dumbledore could have made a difference for minorities like Remus Lupin, but chose to turn down the chance to create real change.
Dumbledore’s actions and conversations during his frustration and inexperience may have contributed to his decision to turn down the Ministry. While it is likely that Dumbledore would have grown older and matured, he may have felt that the risk was not worth the risk.
Why did Harry Potter not become the minister of magic?
Following the conclusion of the Battle of Hogwarts, Harry Potter was not appointed to the position of Minister for Magic. Instead, he assumed the role of Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement, a department of significant importance within the Ministry. Notwithstanding his aspiration to assume this role, Harry does not evince a particular affinity for it.
Was Umbridge a Death Eater?
In the Harry Potter series, Dolores Umbridge is depicted as an evil, cruel, authoritarian, bigoted, and despicable woman who represents the worst of political power. She is portrayed as sadistic, corrupt, and even found joy in torturing students. Harry describes her to Sirius Black as vile enough to be a Death Eater. Umbridge is also portrayed as prejudiced, despising half-breeds, Muggle-born witches, and wizards.
She fired Hagrid due to his half-giant birth status and displayed intolerance towards the centaur Firenze. Umbridge is a “pure-blood supremacist” who attempts to mask her half-blood status, often lambasting her Muggle mother and Squib younger brother.
Understanding Umbridge as one of the most despised fictional characters, she is known for her authoritarian stance, dictatorial presence, racist attitudes, and torturing of children. Charlotte Ahlin from Bustle compared Umbridge to Voldemort, stating that she was relatable and relatable, making her a relatable character in the Harry Potter universe.
📹 Why Didn’t Dumbledore Become Minister of Magic?
Albus Dumbledore was clearly an influential and skilled wizard who was offered the position of Minister of Magic countless times …
A. What if Dumbledore never met Grindelwald? How would his life had been, and the kind of person he would’ve? B. Its alright to crave power just don’t let it consume u. Remember Avatar Wan in Legend of Korra, he got to b all powerful (thou he didn’t know the full scale) and was still pure good. Any fiction in where a powerful person losses their abilities but doesn’t let it get them down, great, get their powers back just to feel whole again, not strong…great again on same lvl.
Acting from the position of Hogwarts headmaster gave him much more flexibility. As minister, he would often be bound by unwanted regulations. Besides, he would be in the spotlight, his every decision would be judged. As headmaster,, he could do many things secretly and more effectively than as a minister.
Hey Dean! I rewatched Goblet of Fire recently and I have suggestions for some “what ifs” that I don’t think anyone else has ever covered in-depth in article format: What if Harry’s name was not placed into the Goblet of Fire? What if Harry didn’t compete in the Triwizard Tournament? (Like if Dumbledore agreed with McGonagall and stopped Harry from competing) What if the real Mad-Eye Moody taught DADA in the Goblet of Fire? What if “X”‘s (The “x” standing for anyone’s name, like Ron or Hermione) name was placed into the Goblet of Fire instead of Harry? (This last one doesn’t have to do with Goblet of Fire in particularly) And what if Filch was a wizard? Even though these are slight changes, especially comparing the first and second questions to each other, I feel like a lot could potentially change! Hope you read this and that you have a great day!
He knew how much power he could willed and how he could fall into previous habits that had wound up costing him so much and that quite frankly scared him so he preferred a position that would allow him to keep himself in check while still providing influence and advice to both young minds as well as those in the ministry
I totally agree with you! I also think, that after what happend with Tom Riddle, he understood, that he can be so much more helpfull to the community of whiches and wizards by taking influence to the students in Hogwarts to avoid rising up another witch or wizard with the same plans and purposes like Voldemort.
I think Dumbledor’s biggest fear was thay he’d become what he and Grindlewald set out to be so many decades earlyer. Top it off with the fact that he effectivly possessed two of The Deathly Hallows (having had The Cloak as well before passing it to Harry) and I wouldnt have put it past him, after succuming to his vices, to use the Ministry to find The Stone as well. With The Ministry at his back, and The Three Hallows in his possessio, a darker Dumbledor could have put even Voldemort to shame had he fallen to The Dark Path.
It makes sense that Dumbledore would turn down the opportunity to become Minister of Magic. With that much power, he can’t trust himself with it. Sure, he is a great man, but he still has a troubled past. Plus, when Voldemort comes into power, Dumbledore can’t look for any Horcruxes since he has to keep the Ministry of Magic from falling apart.
Fudge should have been arrested for endangering the Wizarding World by not doing anything after Harry Potter told him Voldemort had come returned at the end of book 4. Instead, he slanders the boy and Dumbledore through the media. Dumbledore knew his limits and took precautions to not go down that dark path again. I see this as a strength for him. Takes a strong will to turn down the position for that reason.
Albus Dumbledore was extremely powerful, both politically (more-so than the head of any government could ever be) and magically. The bastard took over the three positions that would someone the powerful person in Europe, and he abused it a lot. Edit: As Headmaster Of Hogwarts, he had the ability to influence everyone that could attend Hogwarts, which he did. As Chief Warlock, he had the ability to influence the decisions and laws of his country. As Supreme Mugwump, he could do the same, but for the whole world. He couldn’t have decided to take up the position because of absolute control because that’s exactly what he had with those positions. (Unlike the MOM who actively gives up control.) Edit 2: You say that he was trying to avoid power, but Voldemort tried to get that same position because of the power it offered, he wasn’t trying for DADA professor for fun. He was trying to get power and influence from being the Headmaster. Edit 3: It should be no secret that Albus Dumbledore was a fucking mad man. He actively tried to kill Harry. He likely put Voldemort into the life that he led for influence. He hired Argus Filch into a position that tortured him for the sake of fame and a game. He ignored the fact that Scabbers was obviously an animagus. In short, he was crazy and always power-hungry. Edit 4: He fought against Voldemort?! He actively decided to make a 1 year old boy a martyr for his game. Edit 5: “Can you imagine if Dumbledore wanted to create his own army to preserve the magical sector?
Well I believe that with the 3 positions that he did have gave him much more power and influence over others than he would have had as minister. He shouldn’t have been able to hold the 3 positions at the same time. And because he did he wasn’t able to dedicate enough of his attention to any of them and so I believe that the wizarding world did suffer as a result of this.
On the flat side, not everyone likes politics, and fits in perfectly to it. Also I think, that the social elitism people in the ministry, would quit work if he is in charge, like Lucius Malfoy, and anyone else who believed in blood purity. One thing, that would come out good if he was the minister, is that there would have been massive prosecution against Voldemort and his Death Eaters. Which is also a bad thing, because I think he would focus most of his time on it.
There’s a website called “hogwarts is here”. A fantastic site dedicated to teaching official Hogwarts classes. You have graded exams, online professors and gain access to the hogwarts library where there are countless textbpoks for you to help you study. Im in my first year studying charms and DADA, I’ll be starting herbology, history of magic, potions and astronomy later on in the year. Enrol guys it’s definitely worth it!!!😊
I believe it was his sisters death that causes him not to take the position when his sister died he blamed him self and for punishment he would from what I believe the rest of his life to teach others not to make the same mistakes “seek power and glory” and so he never took the Ministry of magic position cuz than he no longer would be “acknowledging his punishment” and would be following his career aspects like he was doing before his sister died aka he gave up the fame and power as punishment and started to teach as his only way to make things right to me that makes more sense to me than cuz didn’t know if he still lusted for power