The Forsworn Conspiracy quest in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim involves solving a murder case and finding the culprits, with Elthrys suspecting the Forsworn. The quest begins with a local in Markarth searching for the Forsworn inside the Shrine of Talos. To complete the quest, players must heed the guards’ warning and investigate Margret’s room.
Upon arrival in Markarth, players hear an altercation in the open market and encounter Weylin shouting “For the time to uncover a secret plot that has been screwing around in markarth”. The objective is to meet Eltrys inside the Shrine of Talos and investigate Margret’s room. Players can sneak up behind Weylon and do a backstab, but if the kill cam activates, they won’t get an assault.
To complete the quest, players must stealthily kill the middle guard in the Shrine of Talos. To complete the quest, players must open the console and type “setstage ms01 100” to complete the questline and place the Dragonborn in jail. After waking, players must return Elrys after finding each piece of evidence, which will pay them 1000 septims for each one.
The quest may automatically end by handing over Markarth during negotiations, but to end the endless arrest on sight order, players must submit and go to jail, which begins No One Escapes Cidhna Mine. This guide provides a detailed guide to the Forsworn Conspiracy quest in Skyrim.
📹 Skyrim – The Full Story of the Forsworn Conspiracy – Elder Scrolls Lore
In our latest Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim video we uncover the full story of the Forsworn Conspiracy. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is an …
Should I have killed Madanach?
Killing Madanach is a challenging task, as it requires careful execution to prevent other prisioners from rushing to his aid. After his death, take the loot from his body, including a key to the gate outside his chamber, and check Madanach’s chambers for potions. The Dwemer ruins are more dangerous without the Foresworn, with two sets of enemies to kill or sneak past. Kill the first, spiders, and sneak through the second, usually Dwemer Spheres.
After leaving the mines, the Silverblood brother from the previous mission will return all possessions and give you a reward, the Silver-Blood Family Ring, which will improve your armour or weapons by 12. The Armor of the Old Gods light armour set or the Silver-Blood Family Ring are recommended options.
How do you complete The Forsworn Conspiracy?
In this quick walkthrough, you will investigate a murder in Markarth and uncover a sinister plot surrounding the Forsworn. You will meet with Eltrys in the Shrine of Talos to find evidence about Margret, Weylin, Thonar, “N”, and Nepos. If you don’t step in, the guards will kill Weylin, who retorts that he will die for his people. The guards are curt as they try to quell the crowd, but when you ask about the crime and the Forsworn, they tell you that they are just a bunch of madmen and to mind your own business. The goal is to find evidence about Margret, Weylin, Thonar, “N”, and Nepos, and return to the shrine to find the reward.
Is there a way to keep Eltrys alive?
The individual in question is of primary importance until the completion of The Forsworn Conspiracy. Upon the individual’s demise, the quest is deemed complete. To extricate oneself from Cidhna Mine, one must first effect one’s own arrest and subsequently complete the “No One Escapes Cidhna Mine” quest. In the event of an unsuccessful outcome, it is recommended that the key be procured through pickpocketing the Orc or, if feasible, through physical confrontation. This will guarantee that the player is able to complete the quest.
Are you supposed to go to jail in Markarth?
The quest involves a player’s choice between getting arrested or running, with the guards attempting to arrest you every time you enter Markarth. If you run, the guards will attempt to arrest you again. The only way to continue the quest is to get arrested. You can be taken to jail and start the next mission “No one escapes Cidna mine”. Depending on your actions, you will receive one of two apparel rewards, with the second being better for smithing.
You will be attacked every time you enter Markarth. DaJoe86 claims there is no bounty you can pay off, but it is likely that he didn’t have the coin to pay it. The bounty is 1000 septims, which is the only way to pay it off.
Can you overthrow the silver bloods?
The text outlines a strategy for completing the civil war and speaking to Ulfric or Tullius. To persuade Ulfric, use medium speech and journals from the first quest, or high speech or Thonar’s journal. For Tullius, use high speech or Thonar’s journal. Alternatively, persuade Igmund to let you kill them or intimidate him if you’re very high level and have finished the main quest. Kill the Silver-bloods by putting Thongvor into bleedout mode and following the dialogue path “Markarth will be better without you”.
It’s important to note that dealing with Thongvor should be done after finishing the civil war, as it may cause strangeness if the imperials lose Markarth in season unending. The mod is considered a beta, as the author is currently the only person who has tested it and is mostly unvoiced until they find the inclination to cut some vanilla voice lines together. The author will remove the mod once it’s up for a month with no unresolved bug reports. Feedback is welcome while the mod is still in beta.
Is it possible to save Thonar’s wife?
Thonar, a character in a quest, spends her time reading in a chair at the Treasury House. If questioned, she is killed by Nana Ildene in a scripted death. If not questioned, she will survive the quest and return to her daily routine. Thonar sleeps in her bedroom from 10pm to 6am and spends the day eating, cooking, relaxing, or reading. She pauses for a meal between 9am and 8pm. She wears fine clothes, boots, an iron dagger, a key to the Treasury House, and a selection of higher-class loot and gold.
Is there a way to break out of Cidhna Mine?
It is recommended that Madanach be killed, either by surprise or by informing him, and that his body be used as a means of obtaining a note and key to unlock the gate and leave the Cidhna Mine. The exit tunnel will be situated in proximity to hostile entities, including frostbite spiders and Dwarven Spheres. Should the player successfully navigate their way out of the Cidhna Mine, Thonar will restore their equipment and bestow upon them the Silver-Blood Family Ring as a reward.
Can you spare Grisvar the Unlucky?
In this text, players are given the task of listening to Madanach, a character who asks players to prove loyalty by killing Grisvar the Unlucky. If they give their shiv to Borkul, Madanach will give them a new one and send them to kill Grisvar. Once Grisvar is dead, they can speak with Madanach and become an honorary member of the Forsworn. If they choose to kill Madanach, they can either inform him or surprise attack him. After he is dead, they can use a note and key to unlock the gate and leave the Cidhna Mine.
Can you save a Thonar wife?
Thonar, a character in a quest, spends her time reading in a chair at the Treasury House. If questioned, she is killed by Nana Ildene in a scripted death. If not questioned, she will survive the quest and return to her daily routine. Thonar sleeps in her bedroom from 10pm to 6am and spends the day eating, cooking, relaxing, or reading. She pauses for a meal between 9am and 8pm. She wears fine clothes, boots, an iron dagger, a key to the Treasury House, and a selection of higher-class loot and gold.
Do you get your stuff back after the Forsworn conspiracy?
Escape after killing Madanach and receive your equipment returned by Thonar and the Silver-Blood Family Ring. If you escape with Madanach, Kaie, a member of the Forsworn, returns your equipment and the Armor of the Old Gods. The quest continues until Madanach is confronted by Thonar, leading to a fight that kills Thonar and turns guards and citizens hostile towards the Forsworn. You can participate in the battle or wait until midnight near the exit tunnel. Depending on your route, you will receive either the Silver-Blood Family Ring or the Armor of the Old Gods.
Is Madanach a bad guy?
Madanach, the leader of the Forsworn, is a rebel group of Reachmen who conquered The Reach during the Great War with the Aldmeri Dominion. They established an independent kingdom, ruled for two years, and were criticized for their chaotic uprising. After the war, Madanach petitioned the Empire to recognize The Reach as a legitimate kingdom. Jarl Hrolfdir and his son Igmund sought help from Ulfric Stormcloak and his militia to reclaim the Reach. Ulfric agreed to reclaim Markarth for Hrolfdir, but only if the people of the Reach could worship Talos.
Madanach was captured and sentenced to death, but his execution was overturned by Thonar Silver-Blood, who saw the Madanach and the Forsworn as useful to him. In exchange for his life, Madanach would command the Forsworn to perform Thonar’s bidding from behind bars, such as attacking mines to force owners to sell their lands to the Silver-Bloods in exchange for their protection. This allowed Thonar to consolidate his power throughout the Reach and aquire vast wealth, which he used to keep the Hold Guards in his pocket and prevent investigations into the Forsworn attacks.
📹 Skyrim: Special Edition Walkthrough Part 35: The Forsworn Conspiracy
I assist a local in Markarth in his search to stop the Forsworn inside the city.
I thought Escape from Cidhna Mine was absolutely amazing. I was so immersed in the amazing story. At the end, I helped slay some guards with the Forsworn. It was great until they ran away and I didn’t realize, so I kept attacking the guards until I got a bounty. Later on, Forsworn in the wild continued to attack me. Sigh… Skyrim. So immersive.
Option 3: Step 1) Kill Madanach Step 2) Escape the mine Step 3) “Thank” Thonar for arranging your pardon. Collect the ring. Step 4) Get the ebony blade Step 5) Get the Ritual Stone blessing. Step 6) Scour all the resurrection scrolls possible. Step 7) become a vampire. Step 8) get all the pickpocket enchanted items you can equip at the same time. Step 9) visit your old friend Thonar at night. Step 10) pickpocket his sleeping ass. Step 11) bite his conspiring ass for blood. Step 12) sneak attack his ass while sleeping with whatever weapon one shots him. His bodyguard wont mind what happens next as long as you haven’t been detected by this step. Step 13) revive his ass with the stone power. Step 14) pull out the ebony blade. Get to work. Step 15) revive his ass with a scroll. If you use a regular spell the next time you kill him he’ll turn to ash and get off easy. Step 16) repeat step 14 as many times as possible. Get your ebony blade maxed out without the guilt trip. Lol at the comments made by his bodyguard as he sees his former master brought back from the dead and killed again over and over. He might even join in putting him down! Step 17) leave Markarth by fast travel. Step 18) talk to the friendly courier. He will have an inheritance letter from Thonar’s dumb ass. Step 19) profit!
Skyrim is so deep when you look at it. On my first play through the choices seemed easy and clear. Stormcloaks, elves bad, empire bad, nords good. But on looking at the empire and the actual war then treaty, it’s hard to make a decision on who to side with. Same with this. On your first run it is clear to kill Madanoch and boom you’re good, but when you look closer, it’s hard to chose. I love Skyrim.
The best ending for this is to be a double agent. Help the king in rags escape, but just at the last door kill each of those forsworn just before they gain the freedom they so desperately wanted. After this, when you exit and are given the silver blood ring assassinate Thonar. With this choice your then the hero as you cut off each of the bad branches. As a bonus, since the quest is completed all npcs active in it are no longer essential. So for more of a role play you can root out all of the corruption by assassinating each npc present in this little scheme.
I hate the forsworn so much before I got to markarth they attacked me and killed my horse. Then when I raided their cave I found horse meat. THOSE ANIMALS BUTCHERED MY HORSE! from the moment on I showed the forsworn no mercy i hunted them down and ruthlessly struck down all forsworn I could find. To avenge my sweetfoot.
Two things that hit me in the guts when I played it. Firstly, that Eltrys’ wife was Rhiada, who usually gets killed when the Forsworn attack while you’re talking to Thonar. Bye-bye Eltrys’ wife and baby, never born. Second, Uraccen lets slip that his daughter is Uaile, who you have to kill when escaping Nepos’ house. This whole quest is such a downer.
I couldn’t betray Grisvar! I promised him I wouldn’t kill him before talking to Madanach. And he’s a nice guy! Madanach’s a bloodthirsty monster, and so is every other Forsworn in the mine. Am I sympathetic? Absolutely. But am I going to free them when they tell me the first thing they’ll do is kill as many people as possible? No way. They all die. And then Thonar dies too, for throwing me in the mine and for his blatant disrespect for life. Though his death is via assassination, of course. Wouldn’t want to lose my pardon and my status as a hero of Markarth, now would I?
A missed opportunity in Skyrim is having the Civil War quest worl like Fallout New Vegas, where your commander sends you to various cities to either gain the support of or destroy certain factions as a way of introducing quests to players. For example, Tullius has received reports of something going on in Markarth. He has an agent there, and wants you to meet up with them in the Silver Blood Inn. Well, you see her either get murdered or talk to her, and when you get to the ending, if you’re with the Legion, you have a third option: convince Madanach to side with the Legion. Maybe a sort of compromise: those responsible for the atrocities committed against the Reachmen will be duly punished under Imperial law, and a section of land will be given for the Forsworn that is theirs, alongside allowing Reachmen to come and go through Markarth as they please.
I remember from the last time I played Skyrim, I sided with Madanach, however during the escape through the Dwemer ruins, I intentionally sabotaged their escape, luring Dwarven Animunculi (The Spiders, Spheres, etc) to the group, moved them directly into the path of traps, etc. Just before the exit back into Markarth, all that was left was my Dragonborn and Madanach. I accepted the Armor of the Old Gods before I then killed him before the doors. I then exited to be rewarded by Thonar Silver-Blood. I accepted my reward of the Silver-Blood Family Ring, then I blasted Thonar in the back of the head with my Dwarven Crossbow, killing him. Afterwords I made a very quick escape from the city, returning to my explorations of Skyrim.
I can see almost an exact replica to Irish history in this storyline. A group of guerrilla fighters trying to claim back their home, an uprising while the occupiers were at war, mass executions and imprisonment, organising the cause from behind bars to show strength. Mental tbh but maybe I’m just a nerd
I prefer siding with Madanach because Thonar is a corrupt prick and I like the way Druadach Redoubt becomes full of friendly Forsworn. Mind, it’s worth mentioning you can kill Thonar if you sided with him as he loses his essential status after completion of this quest. It essentially allows for a “third option” in sense, where you refuse to side with the Forsworn whilst also double crossing the puppetmaster.
Play as a stormcloak-aligned nord(/character in general) : side with Thonar. Play as a forsworn breton (or orc) : side with Madanach. Play as a dunmer : side with Madanach, betray him and get both rewards. Play as anything else and do whatever we want (just try to save Margret if you are imperial-aligned). Roleplay 101
I sided with Madanach you don’t have to fight your way through the city if you don’t want to. I thought fighting with guards like that would end badly, so I just hung out outside the door and watched the fighting below. It was also helpful when getting Logrof the willful since they were friendly and wasn’t that interested in their prisoner.
After the first time I went through this quest, I always play it the same way. Side with Madanach until we get through the ruins, get the fancy old god dear, then kill him. Thonar shows up and give me his fancy ring, gets killed by the foresworn mob, I help kill the foresworn. Evil is punished, and I gets ALLLLLLLLLLLLL that sweet sweet loot.
I remember this quest… it’s how one murder in Markarth escalated to a genocide of the entire province by a rampaging dragonborn. (I killed all the guards because that’s what usually happens when I get arrested and can’t talk my way out, and killed them gladly this time because they were actually corrupt) then I decided “fuck it, if I’m going to kill everyone in one hold, might as well kill everyone, period. None of the NPCs treat me with respect anyway.” so I broke out of Markarth while riding a dragon, then I fast traveled to each major city, and slaughtered everybody, no survivors… well, except for the essential characters.
As much as I loathe Thonar and his family, I side with them because I feel there’s less blood on my hands that way; what the Silver-Bloods do is horrible and wicked, but they don’t kill indiscriminately. They send their goons to kill off threats to them directly in the vicinity of Markarth whereas the Forsworn are all over the Reach and expanding out towards the tundra of central Skyrim where they DO kill indiscriminately. Hundreds of them pick off caravans, innocent hikers, and even a young woman who just wanted to have a nice swim simply because they didn’t like them being there. (Not to mention how many innocents are killed by Madanach and his friendos when they escape Cidhna Mine…) It’s a rock and a hard place choice, but I think it’s best to try and aim for an option that spills the least blood…Besides, you can always go back and pick off the Silver-Bloods yourself thus getting rid of BOTH sides of bad actors. ;P
I think I killed Madanach, but only just before exiting the ruins. Then I made sure the rest of the Forsworn died and the only civilians that died were the guards, since I want Markarth to stay populated. This way, I got the Armor of the Old Gods and I got Thonar’s ring, and I can kill Thonar whenever I want (since he isn’t essential).
When I played it recently, I managed to go into Markarth from the Jarls place and sniped Weylin. I talked to Margaret, pickpocketed Thronir, escaped the city as a Fugitive. Tried to sneak back in and went back into the city pretending to be a Markarth Guard, which didn’t work. After being in the mine I intended, based on the journal, to kill Madanauch and escape alone. In previous playthroughs I never knew I could kill the King in Rags or even that I could surpass the fight with Nepos the Nose.
For anyone else wondering what race Reachmen are, since they are in Skyrim but talk about “the Nords”, I checked it out: ethnically speaking (and for game mechanics too) Reachmen are Bretons, but culturally speaking they’re considered a different group, as neither Bretons nor Reachmen consider Reachmen to be Bretons.
I just killed my way out of Markarth and paid the fine (at least I think I did), forgetting all about the quest due to it’s dull conclusion. With the same character, but later, I accepted going into prison since I started enjoying escaping them. So I found the Forsworn king, talked with him and killed him! Then the Silver-blood guy came and congratulated me for killing the king and escaping. All I could think of was “Who the hell is this guy?”
I did this in a way no one has done. I killed weylin, let margret survive, talked to eltrys, went to the miners, asked for info on weylin, got to the warrens, bribed the key passer, went to weylin’s room, got the note, fought dyrstren, made him submit got the lead on nepos, returned to eltrys to get a juicy 1000 septim reward, left to find info on margret, grabbed the key to her room that was on the counter next to kleppr in the silverblood inn, went to her room, stole her diary, got threatened by a guard to stop snooping, returned to eltrys with the info on the diary, he paid me 1200 septims this time, then went to the treasury house, bribed the maid to let me pass, confronted thonar, his wife got murdered and zombified, killed his servants and his wife turned to ash, confronted him one more time, he revealed the truth, left to face nepos next, ualei didn’t want me to go inside, nepos granted my wish, confronted him, he told me everything, afterwards i killed his 3 servants and him, left to go back to eltrys, found him dead inside, guards said i was under arrest, i submitted to them, got dragged off to cidhna mine, while inside i approached borkul i persuaded him to let me talk directly to madanach, once inside madanach asked me what it was that I wanted, I said “let’s start with revenge”, this angered madanach and i killed him, shortly after i read his message about an abandoned pipeline i heard the other prisioners that were on his side approaching me to investigate the screams, i killed them in a long worned out battle, even the silver blood guards upstairs were targetting me for creating chaos, so after i killed all the prisioners except for grisvar the unlucky, i started casting spells through the iron door frame to hit the silver blood guards outside, i killed them all and left through the old abandoned markarth pipes to reach for my freedom, once inside i saw an angry thonar swinging his blade at me, i swung back and got no bounty, i then submitted him to defeat and using a mod called defeat, i tied him and talked to him, he rewarded me with his family ring and then i proceeded to kill him too.
Alternatively, you can initially join the forsworn, get the unique forsworn gear, and then stab Madanach in the back, when his men are not close. When you exit the mine, the forsworn will attack you, but you can overpower them with the help of the Markarth guards. This way you will also receive the silver-blood ring. As far as i know, there are no complications, bugs, anomalies caused in the story by this.
I wish the forsworn had been by default a joinable faction. Perhaps you could help lead them to victory in battle, defeating imperial and stormcloak forces alike to drive them from the reach. Perhaps you could ally with either of the 2 major factions to secure an independent reach. Maybe even negotiate a covert arrangement with the thalmor for equipment and provisions in exchange for further diverting imperial resources and subverting stormcloak ambitions in the area. Seeing the forsworn grow from a ragtag guerrilla band into a formidable army would be amazing.
Other than the “everybody sucks” aspect, this isn’t much of a moral dilemma. The Silverbloods, bad as they are, generally don’t enslave and kill innocent people or kidnap children as sacrifices to friggin’ Hagravens. They certainly don’t seem to be all about constructing a whole kingdom out of that. But even if there were a moral equivalency, the Nords are more civilized than the useless Reachmen. You can buy useful stuff from Nords, while the Forsworn mostly just drop crappy loot. Not a contest, Skyrim for the Nords.
Solitude’s is much worse. Roggvir didn’t do anything illegal. Ulfric challenged Torryg legally and then the imperial army wants to kill him. He is the true High King. Roggvir is innocent. Sometimes I just kill every bystander and let roggvir free. He has a scripted death tho it’s pretty sad. Then I just resurrect him or spawn him in Windhelm
I heard there was an exploit were you could kill Madanarc and Thonar while getting the unique ring and the Forsworn at the redubt on your side. But you slightly convince me to just let Thonar die. I killed Madanarc once but it was because I failed the pickpocket and everyone aggroed on me. So I just went on a killfest and left it at that.
Lol I had to reload when I first when to maarkarth had to save the lady lol 😆, I’m always to nice in Skyrim hahahah. And I look up this quest as a walkthrough and there’s a third option I tried to screw them both over when you leave the mine, you get to the end and can take them on when they just leave to go through door lol I can say it didn’t go well lol. They all come back in and it was on 😝
They will eventually take back what is rightfully theirs. Although, what became of the Forsworn is a much more conflicted topic. Their way of actually taking it back turned into a poorly executed mess which attracted liable recruits, thus repeating the cycle of insanity and vengeance. Theres a detailed article about this on my website(Shameless plug)
After my very first play-through, I knew what to expect and make a point to save Margret all the time. I also side with the Forsworn every single time I play through this game! For all their talk about how “Skyrim belongs to the Nords” and wanting to rule their own land their way, Ulfric and his Stormcloaks turn a blind, hypocritical eye to the Reachmen. And the Silverbloods (Thonar especially) just disgust me to no end. As does Maven Blackbriar, but there is literally nothing I can do about that. Side with the Empire and she becomes Jarl of the Rift; side with the Stormcloaks and she continues on as she did before. Lose-lose situation with her. I only wish that you could legitimately join the Forsworn faction in the game, optimally when you side with Madanach in Cidhna Mine. That way, the Dragonborn is given a chance to lend his or her voice to their cause, and it would keep you and your followers from being attacked all the damn time by Forsworn in the Reach.
But which one is the Lesser of 2 Evils? The Silver-Bloods? Or the Forsworn? On 1 hand, if you help the King in Rags, you get a full set of fully Enchanted Armor, and Markarth is Mostly Free from Silver-Blood Corruption. On the other, you might get a Nifty Ring, killed the Forsworn King in Rags, but Corruption is still High, Silver-Bloods still have more control. But here is the other side, you are the Dragonborn, you can Lay Claim to anything, because you are already held in Godliness by most of Skyrim, so if you were to mention that you are the Dragonborn, would the Corrupt Markarth Guards actually pull their heads from their Asses? By the way, why can’t you tell people that you are the Mythical Dragonborn to begin with?
Uccaren talks about his daughter, not moments ago his daughter was killed. Though one time, in a playthrough where I destroyed the Dark Brotherhood then married Muiri by furying Bothella then investing with Muiri when she took over the shop. Met Odvan later in the mine, “I wonder how Grandmother Bothella is doing. Probably worried sick.” Don’t worry, she isn’t worried or sick.
Fudgemuppet, I have been perusal your articles with a lot of joy for quite some time now. The many unique builds you create are just incredible. Would you be be able to create an Argonian light armored (one handed weapon wielding) Battlemage ? I am starting one soon and I would like to see you guys make a sick build out of it. I would be so very grateful if you did!😀 Thanks for looking at this comment😃
Was it ever explained how the orders got from Madanach to Nepos. Seems Thonar was using them as his sort of personal assassins in exchange Madanach could also give his own orders as long as they didn’t attack the Silver Bloods. Also appears that the Forsworn(even Nepos) don’t know that Madanach is taking some of the orders from Thonar. As far as Nepos knows Weylin attacking Margaret was Madanach’s order as much as Ildene attacking Betrid was. I had this idea. Thonar knows about the tunnel. That’s clear, he’s waiting at the exit whichever option you take. He doesn’t need to use it though, his mercenaries can give Madanach notes from Thonar. Somebody serving the Silver-Bloods who is actually a Forsworn agent has a key to the Markarth ruins. Say Kaie for example. Maybe somebody emerged from the tunnel on day, Thonar or a mercenary, sure to be in plain view of Kaie, and “accidentally” dropped the key. Now Kaie thinks she has access to Madanach. She goes in, speaks to him, gets the orders thinking they are all his, some will be, some are from Thonar. She then leaves and gives the orders to Nepos to carry out. Maybe at some point she made a copy of the key to give to him. This way Nepos has an agent that he thinks is fooling Thonar and getting orders directly from Madanach, the agent thinks this as well, but Madanach’s orders are also mixed in with Thonar’s.
Honestly, I hated both sides so much… I just murdered them both. The moment I got close to Madanach, I killed him in vengeance for eltrys. I killed as much of the Markarth City Guard as I could, at least, the ones that seemed the most corrupt (Had suspect voicelines, or were the ones who killed Eltrys), and then, when I escaped from the mine, I murdered Thornar as well. Damn shame there’s no like… ‘escape the city before you’re captured’ objective… paired with like, being allowed to go John Wick on Madanach and the Silverbloods… but it’s about as close as I can get.
Uraccen “I left behind my daughter Uaile when I was taken.” Dragonborn: “yeah, well, I got News for you, it turns out she was trained/raised/employed by the forsworn in assistance of Nepo and madanach” Uraccen: “what?!? No! That’s not what i wanted for her!! She was supposed to have a normal youth!! Madanach assured me of that!!” Dragonborn: “and sadly enough her employance with the forsworn got her killed” Uraccen: what!?! How?!? Dragonborn: “I was at the wrong place at the wrong time when it happened, i was investigating the involvement of nepo, i confronted him in his house after a maid, your daughter, let me through to him, his staff including your daughter were forsworn operatives, halfway during our conversation the city guard burst into nepo’s house and it became a confrontational massascre, besides me everyone who was forsworn was killed”
In all reality the only ally the reachmen have are the Thalmor they are the mostly likely to ally with the Forsworn. I sympathetic to their plight, sadly either side of the civil war hate the Reachmen. If we had a third option where we take over Skyrim and mabye even the Empire I would give the reach to the Forsworn and make it a principality with a equal level of autonomy as Skyrim. The silverblood family would have its mines stripped from them and given to the Reachmen. The Nords in the Reach would have safety and protection as aswell as a gerente of representation on Mananoch’s council.
I do not like Markarth and I only went there to deliver the letter for the fish merchant from Riften. I got in and out without receiving the letter from the young man, so I wouldn’t get the conspiracy quest, and I’ve never gone back. I just complete my search missions around in the Reach areas and then get out. I just don’t like that quest, and do not care much for that area in Skyrim. My character tries never to break any laws, so I never get arrested or fined. He’s more of a “Dirty Harry” type of hero.
I really hope Bethesda try to avoid these half finished storylines in the future. It feels like the quest is really picking up momentum when you help Madanach escape from Cidhna Mine. I remember thinking this must be the end of the prologue, exciting things to come. Madanach is free and now he’s going to unite the Forsworn and take back his land. Will I be able to help him in the rebellion? Will there be a siege on Markarth which could change the game world? No, the quest just ends. Does Madanach do anything at all after he escapes? No. For me it would have been better if they didn’t include any of this storyline at all, having the quest end and not go anywhere is so much more disappointing. I’m guessing they thought it would be too similar to the Stormcloaks questline to have another rebellion going on but then it’s confusing why they didn’t cut it completely. Anyways, I wish they made it into DLC and fully fleshed it out.
Wanna cleanse Markarth? Listen well kiddo. Step 1) Do the Forsworn Conspiracy. Make sure you investigate all the leads before reporting to Eltrys, resulting in the maximum possible deaths of Forsworn/Silver-Blood agents. Step 2) Do the No One Escapes Cidhna Mine quest. Kill Madanach in his cell. Then escape. Thonar will greet and reward you – when he turns away to leave, sneak up behind him and cut his throat. Step 3) Do the main questline as normal. Give Markarth to the Stormcloaks in Season Unending. Step 4) After the Main Questline is complete, join the Legion and drive the Stormcloaks out of Markarth. With Thongvor exiled to Windhelm and Thonar dead, the Silver-Bloods no longer hold any sway. Step 5) Assassinate Ondolemar and his Thalmor entourage. Step 6) Do the Taste of Death quest. Play along and lure the priest to the crypt… so you can slaughter all the cannibals. Step 7) You have successfully driven the Forsworn leadership from Markarth, removed the Silver-Bloods from power, ended the cannibalism problem, and slaughtered the Thalmor… but your work is not yet done.
I went to Cidna Mine, pickpocket a Skooma, gave it to The Beast then went and fucking murdered Madanach, because no one fucks with me. Then I turned into a werewolf, ate his heart and fucking killed everyone in the mine, because no one fucks with me. Then I got out, Talked to Thonar, got a shitty ring, sneaked right behind him and sliced his throat. Beacuse. No one. Fucks. With me.
So this is an interesting questline. While in-game I helped Madanach escape, my personal head-canon has a slightly different ending. Seeing the similarities in the plights of the Forsworn, the Dragonborn calls for an audience with High King Ulfric Stormcloak, and demands that he acknowledges the sovereignty of the Reach. Ulfric is angry at first, a clash of Dragon Shouts cracks the strong Dwemer stone, then Ulfric concedes. Madanach is enthroned within Understone Keep, and the treacherous Thonar Silver-blood executed for his crimes. While some restless nords flee the new sovereignty, many stay, and per agreement with Ulfric and the Dragonborn, are treated well within the new nation.
I would feel worse for the Forsworn if their religion didn’t include ritual sacrifice and daedra worship (not the Princes, mind you, I mean daedra in general). Forsworn fans like to equate the worship of Talos with the worship of the old gods, despite the fact that Aedra worship doesn’t entail attacking innocent passerby and slaughtering them. Not to mention the kidnapping of the Sibyl of Dibella, AND the fact that even if you help Madanach during this quest, the Forsworn will still attack you on sight. While I find the story itself interesting and have taken both sides on different playthroughs, I just can’t bring myself to like them. They’re a bunch of cowards who attack random people instead of going for the source of their problems– ironically, the man fighting for freedom of religion– Ulfric Stormcloak.
Killing Madanach AND Thonar is the only way I come away from this quest line happy. I also kill the corrupt guards that murdered the poor guy at the shrine, and surrender to the reinforcing guards. I kill the violent or wicked prisoners in Cidhna Mine before my escape. My Skyrim characters can be rather intolerant of wickedness and corruption.
I’ve looked all over the internet for someone who has noticed the same thing as me but I can’t find anything anywhere. So, I always liked it when Nepos the Nose would say, “My dear boy, what makes you think you’re getting out of here alive” until I just did the quest with Erik the Slayer where you discover the secret behind Rorikstead’s thriving crops. I got the evidence and confronted Jouane on it and he literally says THE EXACT SAME THING, “My dear boy, what makes you think you’re getting out of here alive” It was then that I noticed that their voices were exactly the same too. It completely ruined the immersion for me and I think it is really lazy, like they couldn’t be bothered to have him say something different?? Nope, literally the exact same line using the same voice actor. I love Skyrim but this quest totally sucked. I tried completing it in different ways by speaking to other relevant NPCs in Rorikstead but Rorik just wouldn’t believe me, even when I had the book, same with the elf who is involved in it all. I was forced to kill Jouane when he attacked me and now Rorik’s attitude has changed toward me. I’m trying to play as a “good character” and I just think it sucked that I couldn’t find any other way to complete the quest other than get the same voice line from the same voice actor and be disliked by the owner of the town where I am tryin to get into everyone’s good books as I am playing a Redguard with a mod added that gives you “reputation” and as a Reguard I am treated with suspicion, so I’m trying to be helpful and honorable.
My favourite part of this quest is killing all the infiltrated forsworn in Thonnar’s house before talking to him. If you do it, his wife will still die, but for no reason at all. Basically she “dies from death” which is fucking hilarious because Thonnar’s script won’t even change, still blaming the forsworn and all.
If the reach belongs to the Forsworn then why is Markarth a Dwarven Ruin? The Dwarven people disappeared when? In the second or third era. So technically the reach belongs to the Dwarven people wherever they are. Also, the Dwarves are Elves FYI. Let us also discuss the fact that a Dragon Priest tomb or two is located in the reach and the Dragon Priest ruled Skyrim during either the Merathic or first era so maybe it was their land. Either way, it wasn’t the Forsworn’s lands. It is similar to saying Skyrim or Tamerial belongs to the “Nords” or “Imperials” when the Elves traveled to Tamerial and lived there first during the Marathic era. Most Elven races that moved to and settled on Tamerial have long since disappeared or been whipped out but a few remain. The Merathic era is set after the Dawn era which is when the physical world was created. Skyrim is set in either the fourth or fifth era. So Dawn, Merathic, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th eras. Each era is hundreds to thousands of years long. Oh and by the way it’s either the Dawn or Merathic era or both Eras the dates aren’t recorded so those eras could have been millions of years long to a few days long.
I managed to do the ‘playing both sides’ trick and got the armour of the old gods set (even though I’ll never wear it, ’cause I hate the design of headpiece on females) before Madanach could walk out of the ruins and then I attacked him. His followers came at me in the ruins and it was quite hard to put them all down, I used a scroll of mass paralysis on them and during the charging of the spell alone they managed to eat away at my health. I eventually put the sanguine rose to use at one stage and then activated my Ancestor’s Wrath power, the fire that cloaked me finally got rid of the rest of them. Since the fighting was all happening in the ruins, no citizens of Markarth were harmed. AND when I exited the ruins, Thonar was there and gave me the ring and I got an apology from Igmund. And managed to do the trick right and make the Forsworn at Druadach non-hostile to me, even though I killed Madanach and his posse. So in essence, I got the best of both worlds (in my opinion) by the skin of my teeth because the fight costed a handful of potions of vigorous healing and got me quite a few close calls (I managed to not die at all). EDIT: It’s also likely a good thing a chose to backstab Madanach anyway because when he gave me my stuff back NONE of my quest items were returned, but when Thonar gave me my stuff back I DID get ALL of my quest items back (probably because of a bug)
Some things on this; It never occurred to me that there was a choice. Silver-Blood bad, Forsworn were merely barbarians. It wasn’t until looking on the wiki that I realized I could choose to kill Madanach and would support Thonar for doing so. I’ve yet to make a character that would not, for various reason, support the Forsworn. In fact, I don’t even do Season Unending because it puts a Silver Blood in charge here. Really, this questline is a large part of why I can’t see the stormcloaks as anything but terrible (not that the other two choices in the Civil War are much better…) You can save some lives by pickpocketing (as you pointed out). If you read the notes Thonar and Nepos hold, you avoid the fights that happen near them. But what I (accidentally) found out recently is that you don’t actually have to take the note (and thus can avoid actually pickpocketing). You just use the ‘equip’ action and it lets you read the notes straight out of their pockets without taking them. You also don’t have to kill Grisvar. He does have to die, however. My first character who went in the mines was planning on trying to talk to Grisvar and find a more peaceful solution. Grisvar ran off and I just stood there. The other prisoners killed him.
Every time I did this quest, Thonar survives the Forsworn attack/escape from Markarth and just runs back to The Treasury House like a little girl…unless I personally kill him fast before he runs away…which I gladly do. Of all the killings in this game, this one was by far the most “enjoyable”. 🙂
This article makes this questline look bug free. I slaughtered the whole city and never returned after this questline. Used all kinds of console commands just to finish it even. I never visit this city even on new saves. I’m scared to walk through the doors even. I don’t want to open up that can of worms ever again. But I might after perusal this article lol
I didn’t actually side with either, while technically siding with both. I helped Madonach and his pals get to the exit, he thanked me for it, and then I killed them all because I just needed their help getting out of the mine and I couldn’t let them raid and pillage unchecked. Then when Thonar came to thank me for killing Madonach, I killed him, since such a horrid man shouldn’t be allowed to walk free. It was a great role playing moment and I was honestly shocked the game let me do it.
I felt so bad for the merchant when I first walked in as sge seemed inacont so I killed evrey forsworn I saw later playthroughs when I lost most of my morals and was willing to do more evil stuff like killing people openly i never did let the merchant die a reminder of my kinder past same reason I always adopt the same 2 girls and move them into my home a reminder of my fist playthrough when I was a hero insted of put for myself
I just played this quest today, one Thonar Silver Blood simply had no reaction to his wife dying. Two Nepos didn’t become hostile after the conversation, saying something along the line of “you’ll never here alive” and let me calmly leave his home. When I returned to the shrine of Talos the guards gave the interaction after some moving around. I chose to fight my way out. I made my way out and traveled for a good 30 min only to reach a border and be stopped by some guards from the reach… tossing me in the mine. Then I died in the mine trying to mine some silver. And I got sent all the way back to before I entered the shrine of Talos.
I feel like The Forsworn are right they have been tormented and bullied by The Nords,Imperials, and Bretons The Nords,Imperials,and Bretons didn’t care if you were with The Forsworn they would cut a Forsworns childs head off to make them feel terrible and then throw them into The Mine to sit there and root and think about their dead loved ones but its just messed up of what happened to Forsworn members SOME WERENT EVEN APART OF THE FORSWORN AND THEY WERE STILL EITHER EXECUTED OR THROWN IN THE MINE
i actually let madanach live and escape with his people, thing is, as soon as i got a bounty brief about a captain of the foresworn, madanach and his people were in the same cave with the foresworn captain ( briarheart) i had to kill, but becáuse i escaped with him, they were friendly to me, so i just murdered everybody brutally, ate their corpses and threw them in the water
I never liked Markath mainly because of the corruption and i was dissapointed when i tried the civil war with the stormcloack to then see the silverblood being the ruler of that city wich ultimately with the view of skyrim by Ulfric and his Stormcloack led me to go with the imperial most of the time Yet i still killed most of the Thalmor i saw lmao
“Fight through markoth”? You don’t have to fight! I just watched, looting corpses as I go. None of them aggro on you, neither the forsworn nor the guards. If it’s not obvious, I chose the forsworn. It’s like how my people were mostly destroyed as the settlers violently came through(also my people, as were their slaves, but that’s not the point). It gives me a form of vengeance without hurting any real people (and I was unaware that the king in rags wasn’t essential).
I want more lore on the politcal organizations of the forsworn. It seems like they are similar to the Native Americans. Multiple tribes with different beliefs and cultures. Madnach is like the only dude who was barely able to hold the tribes together, similar to Tecumseh who tried founding a Native American “nation.” But how do the hagravens come into play? Are they inchrage of all forsworn tribes or only some? Is Madnach in charge of them or no? I see a lot of sympathizers here with Forsworn. Bruh. They’re killers. They worship Daedra (thats just fucking evil. Daedric Lords are not subtle when it comes to how immoral they act. Like wtf? Its not a question about religion), and they attack you at every turn (thanks Madnach). “sAd sToRy mAdE mE cRy.” I mean its a article game 😂 . Thats just war in general. Mix it in with a guy who wants money and boom you get the Silver-Bloods. Probably a lot of similar stories from the Nords perspective too. Just because they abuse/use power against their enemies doesnt make them evil. I kill Madnach. Every time. Thonar loses power and the Forsworn are dissarrayed. Its a win-win.
I’m a die hard Stormcloak supporter, so I obviously killed Madanach. Fuck the Reachmen. The Silverbloods support the Stormcloaks, so I’m all good with them lol. However, I didn’t kill Madanach until after we escaped the prison and he gave me the Armor of the Old Gods. Before he could leave the ruins, I decapitated him.
Honestly, if I had the authority within the world of Skyrim to settle the dispute between the Forsworn, the Nords, and the Empire I would do it like this: I would declare Markarth a city-state and the hold of The Reach as independent, BUT still a province of Skyrim. I would allow the Forsworn to worship their gods AS LONG AS there is no human sacrifice and to not torment other worshippers and their own religion. Daedric worship is allowed. Furthermore, all lands seized by the Silver-Bloods will be returned their rightful owners or their next of kin. This includes mines and farmlands. As an independent region, The Reach is excluded from the civil war as long as it stays loyal to the Empire. BUT, as still a hold of Skyrim the Jarl of Markarth can still convene at The Moot to elect a new High King for Skyrim. Plus, do not murder travelers and traders unless they obviously trespassed on private property.
Ohhhhhhhhh my God Markarth intimidates me, THERE I said it. I don’t care if I have mods, God ring cheat room or whatever…. I’m always hesitant on Markarth. I rather sandbox in Riften than do that in Markarth. I eventually get around to becoming thane in Markarth but sheesh the forsworn conspiracy always burns me out bro. 😒
Playing Skyrim for the first time right now (somehow just never got around to it at the time… …well, not “somehow,” but more of a long, unrelated personal story🤐) and when i got here, it was because i got drunk with that dude and woke up in the temple. my first thought upon leaving the temple was “Wow, this place is really pretty!” after escaping the mines: “this place sucks and i’m leaving and not coming back. unless… i wonder, can stone burn to the ground?”
Kinda dumb you HAVE to go to prison. Like, I’m the Dragonborn, I will slaughter this entire city before I step foot in some prison mine. Feel like after you kill the guards at the shrine, and perhaps a few more, the Jarl himself will come running in and demand you stop. After you tell him who is behind all of the unrest in his town, he would give you the keys to the prison and say “prove it.” After then its some more slaughtering time. I remember killing the guards, and trying to run to the Jarl to inform him only for him and the rest of the city to attack me. Seems super bogus you HAVE to go to prison. But lmk how you would have written the quest friends, if you went to prison or said f that and then just became a bad guy in Makarath.
i stopped playing skyrim a few minutes ago to go to bed, it’s 1am here, and now i am perusal skyrim on YouTube. WHY? why can’t i just go to bed….i guess i am addicted to skyrim in any form. please camel fudged nate stop making skyrim articles for a few days so i get enough sleep, it is hard enough to Close the game itself:)
Hmm.. so.. a side question.. Why don’t the Foresworn retake Markarth now? I did a quick count on the wiki, and together they number over 105 (including briarhearts), all of which are in The Reach already (save for about 4), and lets not forget any hagravens or other creatures which might want to join the fun. I’ve not seen more than 20 guards in Markarth at a time (actually… probably 10). So… besides the wall and gate to the city.. what is stopping them? Why not just rally all of the forsworn to their king, and take Markarth? If for some reason they don’t win outright on the first day, couldn’t they just lay siege and live off the land while the city folk see how long they can last on silver alone?
This one of my favorite Skyrim quests yet something that’s always bothered me is that the Reachmen aka Forsworn claim to be natives of the Reach but there are no Reachmen architecture…if you notice they only inhabit caves, Nordic ruins and Imperial forts with their tents set up around them sometimes. Because the developers made such a point of Reachmen claiming to be natives yet have zero ancient architecture makes me think this isn’t an oversight or purposeful left out. Sus af. Sure it’s possible old wooden settlements were destroyed and simply set up camp at fortified locations afterwards but somehow I doubt it. The Reachmen are high on Copium.
I thought about who to side with for quite some time when I first played that quest. Markarth had at that point been reclaimed by the stormcloaks and the silver-blood family ruled. In the end, I decided to side with the Nord, because the forsworn don´t care who they kill either, and, more importantly, because I thought that Markarth´s silver would be of great use for the Nord in their war against the Dominion.
“This was our land, we were here first”. I’m sorry I don’t recall any Snow Elves counting themselves as Forsworn. But then, to Nords and Bretons their idea of “here first” means” we oppressed the natives and conquered this place first”. The Forsworn are just mad the Nords stole what they’d already stolen.
The way I usually do it for what i consider to be the best ending: start off with doing the main story at least up until you broker temporary peace between the red lads and the stormy bois in High Hrothgar. (This ends with the stormy Bois getting markarth and the silverbloods becoming jarl.) Next do the quest as normal up until Cidnah mine where you side with madanoch. All the way until you get your gear back in which you then proceed to stab that crazy reach man in the back and kill his goons. You leave (with the armor of the old gods) and thonar meets you, thanks you, and gives you some dumb ring. Congratulations you got both rewards and you stopped some crazy hill people who practice dark and unholy magic from continuing to raid and kill innocent people… however, why stop there? After all thonar is kind of a dink too… Bonus step: screw the silver bloods, join the imperials, retake markarth and get them booted from the city effectively taking away everything they ever worked for and achieved. In case you wanted some lore reasons behind my decision, while some of the forsworn has some nice sob stories that doesn’t justify murdering innocent people left and right, however, the silver bloods also murder people left and right and intimidate people to get what they want, which is also wrong. Both of them need to be removed in order to effectively help rid the reach of these scummy criminals. Siding with the empire is always my go to anyways. Don’t get me wrong. The Empire has its ups and downs and I do love my coldy bois and even though i understand ulfrics cry the problem is skyrim on its own will get steamrolled by the thalamor and they are the real enemy.
Join Thonar every time. The Forsworn want to be independent so they can worship the hagravens. This means human sacrifice, dark magic, black soul gems, necromancy, etc… Joining Thonar will keep them under his thumb, which will perhaps result in them dying out in th long run, along with their barbarian religion. The city being controlled by a mobster is worth that imo.
There is a third option which works best if you are a stealth archer, and I also use a bound bow. You kill Madanach and make your escape. On leaving the mine you are met by Thonar Silver Blood. After you have spoken crouch and conjure the bow, which you had ready, and kill Thonar. If his death is not detected you can escape. If it is detected either wait until it has all calmed down or hide by going trough one of the nearby doors. Interestingly his brother will later tell you that Thonar has spoken to him and he thanks you for what you did. Obviously Bethesda did not think of this option.
How My “1 punch Kajit” Joe Exotic handled the situation: 1) put into mine, then kill everyone in it including Madanach (Joe hates being in a cage) 2) escape mine and accept Thronar’s gift (I will never financially recover from this) 3) follow him back to his house and “thank him” with a back break kill animation. (Carol is next) 4) Chug a few blackbriar reserves 5) enter Cidhna Mine; Kill all their guards. 6) Nobody fks with Joe Exotic
Actually here is what I did in my current game play of Skyrim. I destroyed Madanach, then when Thonar was outside giving me my reward, I snuck up on behind him and slit his throat and luckily there were zero witnesses. So you see? I killed two birds with one stone. I killed Madanach because I view the forsworn as inferior creatures and barbarians who need to be subdued, and the reason I killed Thonar was two reasons, one he framed me for a crime I did not commit and two, the Silver bloods needed to be taught a lesson for their treachery.
Skyrim civil war looks like Turkish war of independence. They both came from far away. Conquered new lands. And later they founded an Empire(Septim I mean not Alessian or Reman) Then both Empires lost wars and signed agreements. Which made people angry. So my point is Reachmen is like Kurds in Turkey and forsworn are Kurdish rebels if you know history. Also Mustafa Kemal Atatürk did say “Turkey belongs to the Turks” which in fact isn’t racism. But actually Ataturk Nationalism, which accepted everyone as a Turk if they say they are Turk. Don’t know about Nords though. Which way Ulfric means it.
I literally killed everyone involved in this mess. I first sided with the Forsworn, because I thought the Forsworn would be friendly if I did, but only one little cave full of ’em were friendly. The rest were still their usual agressive selves. Then I went back to Markarth and killed the remaining Silverbloods to see if that would open up any unique dialogue… And because they’re all assholes. It didn’t. So I slaughtered the friendly Forsworn because I was super mad that they were still attacking me outside of their home cave…
I believe that the forsworn have some sort of right, the nords are pissed during Skyrim because the empire is denying them their religious freedom to pray to Talos. But the nords denied the forsworn their right to pray to their gods, and kicked them out of their land. Although it’s not a widespread opinion, I believe that the forsworn are just as much persecuted for their religion as the nords are, and I believe the nords should swallow their fucking pride, and allow the forsworn back into the city’s as long as they can be peaceful
I swear my dumbass didn’t want to side with them so instead of doing the smart thing and having them clear out the tunnels with me, I went wolf form and murdered them all in the prison. I then had to live with my choice of wanting to murder every goddamn thing I saw by killing dwarves spheres with duel wield pickaxes
Helping to find a group of people a land to call their own is a nice thing to do, killing a sad man who has been unlucky in his life so far is NOT a nice thing to do, in a heroes eyes the two deeds wouldn’t add up, although it would make more sense if the unlucky guy was unlucky at being a greedy bad guy just like that silver blood fellow, although i kinda doubt that
For anyone who has played this quest you probably know that when captured by the guards you will be taken and receive a bounty of 1000 but if you are at the shrine before the capture stand by the door and transform into a werewolf or a vampire that way during the transformation you won’t receive a bounty for transforming since you are out of sight then you kill off the guards and once all of them are gone you completed the quest without getting a bounty but you won’t be sent to the mines
so im not sure how to find this secret corridor that travels from jarls quarters and somewhere in the warrens i believe nepos the noses uses it however i believe the tunnel was constructed for a previous jarls but you have to find proof solid proof it actually exsists so we can have nepos thrown into cidna ..anyways ive tried to duplicate this senerio but it illudes me anyways …goodluck hope ive helped you out maybe you can do the ssame for me
hey guys maybe the forsworn are distant relatives of one of the greatest empires of all time The Ayleid’s tthere empire was in cyrodiil and they were beaten by a rebellion and the last king sent as a prisoner to cold harbour the rest of their people are known as wild elves and are forced to live in the forests as the people hate them as they enslaved all of cryrodiil the forswornd are forst people or live near them or live under ground so they also might be of dunmer origin and maybe cross bereeding between The Ayleid and Dunmer made the first forsworn conspirators hating the people outside returning their settlements to their former glory and enslaving all of nirn making a newer and far greater empire.The forsworn so far haven’t taken a settlement and live in their camps so maybe this is only the beginning maybe in the next game most probably in hammerfell the beginning will tell you about the fall of the Nords and imperials
i have done both & really there is no right choice in my opinion i think the fact Thanor losing his wife to the Forsworn was punishment enough, i always pick in the convo ” You deserved this” why well look at the shady stuff the guys done, its better for him to live & have lossed what mattered to him other then the mine then kill him. let His wifes death because of his misdeeds haunt him.
I know the forsworn are Bretons who supposedly came to the reach before the nords but i favor the nords because they have a right to the land as they have earned through blood and sweat they earned Skyrim through conquest so i have to side with the Nords but i don’t condone their cruelty only 70 % of it
You made a hullabaloo killing Madanach surprised his lackeys didn’t rush lmao also you left the locked gate open lmao xD if you choose the option of slaying Madanach the easiest way is to summon the Dremora Butler to get any equipment you have him beforehand and/or use the conjure dagger, sword or bow spell xD not everyone plays a spellsword I suppose but it works if you do 🤷🏼♂️