The “Golden Fire” is a mysterious and powerful magical effect that occurred during the Battle of the Seven Potters. Harry Potter’s wand, which was a magical tool, used to create a powerful jet of golden fire between two wands. This effect occurred when Harry’s wand, on its own volition, attacked Voldemort with a powerful blast of flames, breaking Lucius Malfoy’s wand. Later, Harry told Hermione Granger how he could produce golden flames with his wand without using the wizarding currency of Great Britain, which consisted of gold, silver, and bronze coins.
The “Golden Flame” was a powerful golden burst of energy that may have been used by Voldemort before the Battle of Hogwarts. The magical effect was possibly a spell, possibly a magical effect, that created powerful golden flames. The only known usage of this spell was by Harry against Voldemort. Dumbledore explained it as Harry’s wand recognizing Voldemort and protecting him from him. The golden flame was a spell that Harry’s wand conjured on its own in defense of Harry against a wand it had defeated in Goblet of Fire.
Gold, in its purest form, symbolizes truth, honesty, greed, control, shallow needs, and extravagance. Three times Voldemort tried to kill Harry, the magic from Harry’s wand connected with his curse to transform his murderous intent.
📹 Harry Potter Theory: Golden Flames Explained
Today Ben dives into the wizarding world of Harry Potter with a new theory to explain how Harry ACTUALLY created the golden …
Is Harry a pureblood wizard?
Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, and Ron Weasley are three distinct types of wizards, each with a different bloodline. The Malfoy family, an ancient and prejudiced pure-blood family, claimed to have no Muggles, Squibs, Muggle-borns, or half-bloods in their family tree. Most wizards considered an individual a pure-blood if their parents and grandparents were not Muggles, Squibs, or Muggle-borns. By 1995, the number of pure-blood families was declining, and many attempted to retain their status by marrying only other pure-blood families.
However, this led to inbreeding, with some families, like the Malfoys, allowing half-blood marriages, while others, like the Gaunts, Blacks, and Lestranges, required their families to marry pure-blood individuals to maintain their “pure” bloodline. This refusal to marry Muggles or Muggle-borns has led to difficulties in propagating their families.
What is the deadliest magic in Harry Potter?
The Harry Potter series features a dangerous spell, Avada Kedavra, which is one of three Unforgivable Curses that instantly kills its victim.
Why is Harry’s wand so special?
Harry Potter’s wand, a powerful 11-inch holly wand, is believed to be the ideal pairing for him due to its phoenix feather core, originating from the same bird that produces a feather for Riddle’s wand-Fawkes. The interaction between Harry and Voldemort’s wands, known as Priori Incantatem, created a unique magical effect where their wands recognized each other. Harry’s wand is damaged by Hermione’s blasting curse, forcing him to borrow and command other wands until he kills the Dark Lord and uses the Elder Wand to repair his old friend’s holly feather core.
Tom Riddle’s 13 1/2-inch wand, made of a phoenix feather core, is one of the highest of the breeds, producing Harry Potter wands with the greatest range of power and difficult allegiances. Phoenixes, independent and separate from the world, are the main source of these wands.
What is the strongest magic in Harry Potter?
Harry Potter, a powerful wizard, has used various spells and unforgivable curses during his time at Hogwarts. These spells include Crucio, Expelliarmus, Sectumsempra, Expecto Patronus, and Imperio. Harry’s true potential in the wizarding world is evident by his third year at Hogwarts, where he performs magic with great talent that goes beyond his years and lack of education.
Throughout the Harry Potter series, Harry is presented as one of the most powerful wizards in the Wizarding World, whose skill grows through dedication, teachings, and perseverance. He masters complex spells and even indulges in darker forms of magic and unforgivable curses in dire situations. Harry Potter’s dedication, teachings, and perseverance help him grow in the wizarding world and become one of the prime defenders from the Dark Arts and Voldemort.
What is the golden thing from Harry Potter?
The Snitch is a small, faster, and harder-to-see ball used in Quidditch, with a golden color and a Seeker’s job to circle the game to catch it. Catching the Golden Snitch usually results in victory for the Seeker’s team, but in the 1994 Quidditch World Cup match between Bulgaria and Ireland, Viktor Krum took the Snitch to avoid humiliation for his losing team. Snitches are enchanted to recognize the first human to touch them, and makers wear gloves to prevent disputes during capture.
Why did Harry’s wand shoot gold sparks?
The intention behind Harry’s powerful spell, the golden flame, was not to cause harm to Voldemort. Rather, it was a consequence of the connection between his wand and Voldemort’s wand. This formidable spell was employed to safeguard Harry against a vanquished wand in the context of the Goblet of Fire.
What is the rarest magic in Harry Potter?
Ancient magic, a mysterious and powerful form of magic, was largely forgotten in the wizarding world by the late 19th century. Those who could perceive and wield it were considered to have a unique and rare ability. Ancient magic appeared in traces or “whispers” and could also access unique expressions of ordinary magic, augmenting their spells with increased power and potency. Three known inherent wielders of ancient magic began schooling at Hogwarts in their fifth year, linking the ability with late-blooming. Xenophilius Lovegood believed that love was a great blessing bestowed upon the world by practitioners of ancient magic.
Is Hermione stronger than Harry?
Harry’s Defense Against The Dark Arts O. W. L. results are higher than Hermione’s, with Harry’s defensive abilities giving him an edge in combat. Hermione outperforms Harry in every other lesson, including Charms, Potions, and Transfiguration, which can overwhelm Harry’s defensive skills. Hermione could use another type of magic to defeat Harry in a duel, as her skills are powerful but limited, while Harry’s talents extend across a range of subjects.
What spell killed Voldemort?
Harry Potter’s signature spell, the Disarming Charm, was instrumental in defeating Lord Voldemort during the Battle of Hogwarts. The Elder Wand recognized Harry as its master, strengthening the Disarming Charm. Harry’s powerful spell, indicated by the scarlet jet of light, caused opponents’ wands to fly high out of their hands, resulting in Voldemort’s Killing Curse backfiring onto himself.
What is the gold potion in Harry Potter?
In the potion world, gold is a significant element, as seen in Harry’s Polyjuice Potion and the bottle of Felix Felicis. The golden color of the bottle provides Harry with crucial information about Voldemort’s Horcruxes. Hogwarts, a place of learning and magic, is also associated with gold, as seen in plates, goblets, and the gold and scarlet colors of Gryffindor. Gold is associated with wisdom and knowledge sharing, making it an ideal color for learning. Scarlet and gold are also used in Gringotts Bank, Gryffindor, and Fawkes the phoenix. The enchanted sky in the Great Hall is a “red-glow burst” as Harry faces Voldemort for the last time.
What was the golden spell in Harry Potter?
Harry’s wand had a profound effect on the magical realm, whereby it acknowledged Voldemort as its “brother” and mortal enemy. This resulted in the generation of a formidable golden surge of energy, designated as the “golden flame.” This phenomenon may have been utilized by Voldemort prior to the Battle of Hogwarts.
📹 golden snitch #harrypotter #hogwarts #magic #giftideas #wizard #wizardingworld #goldensnitch
On Pottermore, J.K. Rowling says that wands with phoenix cores have a tendency to perform magic on their own, often to the owner’s dismay. I don’t believe it has anything to do with the horcrux. When Voldemort kills Harry in Deathly Hallows, Harry does not have his phoenix feather wand with him, so his wand does not defend itself.
The golden flame was the pheonix feather core taking liberty. Pottermore states that “They show the most initiative, sometimes acting of their own accord, a quality that many witches and wizards dislike”. This is why I think the golden flames occurred. P.S not dissing the theory, just stating my opinion
Maybe Snape DID use liquid luck the night Lilly died. Liquid Luck isn’t all powerful- it allows you to have favorable outcomes within certain limits. Dumbedore’s Army was completely infused with liquid luck at the end of book 6, and it didn’t stop the Death Eaters from getting in with a werewolf, Bill being mutilated, or the death of Dumbledore. All it did was cause some of the Death Eater’s curses to miss the Army specifically. I mean, you could argue the death of Dumbledore was all part of his plan and the luck wouldn’t have effected that, but the Death Eaters getting in with a werewolf? Bill getting mauled for life? Definitely proves Liquid Luck can’t prevent terrible things from happening.
“I believe that your wand imbibed some of the power and qualities of Voldemort’s wand that night, which is to say that it contained a little of Voldemort himself. So your wand recognized him when he pursued you, recognized a man who was both kin and mortal enemy, and it regurgitated some of his own magic against him, magic much more powerful than anything Lucius’s wand had ever performed. Your wand now contained the power of your enormous courage and of Voldemort’s own deadly skill: What chance did that poor stick of Lucius Malfoy’s stand?” The wand probably imbibed Voldemorts power during priori incantatum when it literally reached into Voldemort’s wand and forced it to regurgitate a shadow of those slain by it. A good theory of what the golden fire is would likely be pheonix fire from the pheonix feather core.
The problem with this theory is that the “Golden Flames” appear once more at the end of the book, in Harry’s final duel with Voldemort. “‘Avada Kedavra!’ ‘Expelliarmus!’ The bang was like a cannon blast, and the golden flames that erupted between them, at the dead center of the circle they had been treading, marked the point where the spells collided.” -The Flaw in the Plan, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows At this point, Harry is no longer a Horcrux (the Horcrux having been destroyed two chapters before their duel), AND Harry no longer has his wand (the Phoenix core wand which “absorbed Voldemort’s power and regurgitated it” earlier). So, this theory (as much as I enjoyed it) AND the book’s explanation fail to tell us why the “Golden Flames” appeared one last time to assist in ending Voldemort’s life. Therefore, we can’t be certain that is why the “Golden Flames” appeared earlier in the book, because they are clearly not dependant on the Phoenix core wand, nor Harry’s state of being a Horcrux.
From Pottermore: “Phoenix feathers are capable of the greatest range of magic, though they may take longer than either unicorn or dragon cores to reveal this. They show the most initiative, sometimes acting of their own accord, a quality that many witches and wizards dislike.” Harry has a phoenix feather wand. It was the wand itself acting on its own that shot gold flames since phoenix feather wands can and will cast whatever spell they want to if the situation calls for it. Sure Harry might have wanted to cast a disarming spell but the wand wanted to murder Voldemort with fire.
Taken from the Horcrux Wiki page: “J. K. Rowling revealed in Pottermore that Prof. Quirinus Quirrell served as a temporary Horcrux when Voldemort’s soul possessed his body during Harry Potter’s first year at Hogwarts. A notable difference, however, is that the piece of soul within Quirrell was able to exist without its container, as it abandoned Quirrell and left him to die in the Underground Chambers. This is due to it being the “main” soul that serves as the awareness and consciousness of Voldemort’s psyche. Based on this, the animals that Voldemort inhabited during his years of exile, such as rats and snakes, can also be considered as temporary Horcruxes.” SIDE NOTE ON HOW HARRY BECAME A HORCRUX: “For instance, Dumbledore explicitly stated that Voldemort’s soul had become so unstable that it simply “broke apart” when Voldemort tried to murder Harry Potter for the first time on October 31, 1981 in Godric’s Hollow.”
I think a horecrux defends itself depending on how much of voldemorts soul is in it. Because in Tom riddles diary had half of Voldemorts soul so it could protect itself better. Harry couldn’t have defended himself as much as that as he has the least amount of voldemorts soul in him (aside from nigini I think)
But also Harry didn’t have HIS wand when Voldemort shot the killing curse at him in the forest. If we remember Harry’s wand was broken. He was using Dracos wand. So I feel that the wand theory still stands. And also we know from Wat ollivander has said about wands is that they have feelings and are basically self aware to a certain degree. “the wand chooses the wizard” so the wand sensing Voldemort is a definite possibility being as how Voldemorts wand was not only Harry’s wands brother and equal but Harry’s wand recognizing Voldemorts power from the previous battle in the graveyard.
You missed the big defense mechanism from the locket: it tried to strangle Harry in the lake when it sensed the sword nearby. I think the theory is sound, but I just happen to think it’s one of the true plot holes. I don’t think there’s any real good explanation for it happening in the chase scene but not at the Ministry.
What if it’s the Horcrux in Harry, the part of Voldemort’s soul, that fights against Voldemort in his physical form ? If you do the math, Harry has a bigger percentage of Voldemort’s soul in him than Voldemort does himself, so maybe the two divided parts of Voldemort’s soul, the one in Harry (that’s bigger) and the one in Voldemort’s body (that’s smaller) are basically fighting each other, for they want to be the ultimate dark lord. It’s basically 2 parts of Voldemort arguing which is the strongest, and because Harry has more of Voldemort’s soul in him, he wins the duel. P.S.: What if Harry is a great wizard BECAUSE of the big chunk of Voldemort that’s in him ? I mean, it already gives him parseltongue, maybe it’s also the reason he is a good wizard ? Maybe without it he’d just be kinda meh
Here’s the problem with liquid luck. 1) Acquire sample of properly brewed liquid luck 2) Drink liquid luck 3) While under effects of liquid luck, brew more liquid luck. The effects will guarantee that you brew it correctly. 4) Repeat as necessary, selling off any excess for massive profit. 5) Break the Harry Potter world.
One problem with this theory is in the chamber of secrets, when harry gets a basilisk tooth in his arm. The basilisk tooth has been proven countless times to easily kill horcruxes. One of two things should have happened in this scenario: 1. Harry should have been immediately killed in the chamber of secrets 2. Golden flames should have murdered the basilisk with no difficulty
I agree with your theory and raise you that the horcrux was part of how Harry knew how to destroy the diary. He wasn’t just getting lucky- the horcrux had actually been part of the wizard who created the diary, so it also understood its properties. Harry didn’t know when he was speaking parseltongue so he wasn’t able to distinguish his own thoughts from the horcrux’s.
I would love a direct response SCB here. Something I never fully accepted is why or more to the point, how, harry ended up a horcruxe in the first place. It’s not as if voldy was trying to make one. He didn’t even know or feel or sence that Harry was holding a fragment of his soul. So the excuse given for how voldies fragment of soul latched itself on to the only living thing in the room makes no sense at all. If horcruxes can be unintentionally made, why are people not unintentionally making them all the time when they die or get murdered? I love the Harry Potter universe as much as the most ardent fans; but let’s keep it real here. Harry turned into a horcruxe to make a plot point work. And I have always believed far from being mapped out from the start, this idea came along much later and this was just another sloppy retcon. And to be blunt, this sort of thing tends to happen quite frequently with JK despite the excellent work in the first series. Harry as a horcruxe is compelling and makes for a good story. But we are all asked to essentially ignore how it happened and just accept it as fact on faith. And I did just that because Harry as a horcruxe works as a plot line. But years on now, and especially in light of how low JK has fallen, these inconsistencies become glaringly apparent. What it boils down to is ” Harry is a horcruxe because I say so, end of discussion ” and that really spoils an otherwise brilliant twist. Here’s the thing, JK’s world is one of magic, she could have invented anything.
I remember in pottermore, Rowling mentioned that some specific wands would act on its own accord in specific situations, and she also mentioned that the “Holy” type of wand wood is very special. Well, i can’t remember everything mentioned in pottermore. if any of you are interested, just go and look it up in the wand section.
I think that liquid luck isn’t a plot hole because I believe that people won’t use it because you have to do it absolutely perfectly, and if you screw up a tiny bit (and you can’t tell in advance), you get bad luck like Snape. So taking it is a gamble. You would either have to be really good, or know someone who is really good, but you still couldn’t be sure it’s good luck.
I chose to believe it’s fawkes protecting Harry, just as he did in the chanber of secretes, it’s his feather in Harrys wand and that core chose to react to voldimort attack during the chase producing golden flames (a phoenix speciality). He always had a Dumbledor helping him, fawkes being the oldest living relative of the family.
Well it says in the books that as the two wands are twins (Voldemort’s and Harry’s) they cannot harm each other. But as Voldemort was using Lucius’ wand Harry’s wand recognised it as a foe so the wand itself produced these flames to protect Harry and itself. Never doubt the power of a wand, in this case I don’t doubt Harry’s wand could’ve beat the elder wand producing those golden flames.
Notice the difference, as well: Harry was incapacitated during the Chase scene, allowing the horcrux to “possess” him. This is visible as his wand and arm seem almost pulled into position by an external force to face his attacker (both in the movie and book). In the other instances, Harry was in full control of himself, despite being scared or caught off guard.
Though this is one of my favourite theories and would love it to be correct I’m not sure it is. I don’t feel like Horcruxes by default have built in defences but that the creators imbue their Horcruxes with these defences in their creation. If this is the case I’m pretty sure it wouldn’t be the Horcrux defending itself as Voldemort didn’t intend to even create this Horcrux.
Excellent explanation on this theory. Here’s another idea. Harry’s wand has a phoenix tail feather core. Voldemort’s does as well, but he wasn’t using it at the time when Harry’s wand produced golden fire. Phoenixes can burst into flames, and then rise from the ashes again. So if a phoenix tail feather wand detects an incoming Avada Kedavra, the tail feather realizes it’s time to die, bursts into golden flames, which stops the killing curse, and the tail feather is born again from the ashes inside the wand. Alternatively, the tail feather doesn’t die since it’s not technically alive, but the golden flames could be produced by the same sort of magic that allows a phoenix to produce those same flames.
someone explained it to me acutely once like so. Priori Incantatum is a recognition phenomenon, the wands sense the sibling and will protect not only their owners but the other wand`s owner too. It takes power into itself from the person its fighting to do this and the wands will try to keep them from killing each other. But i really like the Horcrux Defence Theory better, its cleaner
I honestly think you guys are correct because the Prophecy states “and the dark lord will mark him as his equal, but he will have power the Dark Lord knows not…” I think given he asked Slughorn for the Info on the Hocrux he/we only got the info, we knew, given no one had achieved such a feat. They may not have known at the time that the Hocrux would defend themselves especially with all the precautions Voldemort took with the Locket!
Alohamora is used for when they disarm someone: that’s how they locked siruis in the castle in POA: he had no wand. And Harry’s wand shooting out gold sparks had happened before: in book four, gold sparks and a phoenix song, when Harry’s wand spell hit Voldemorts spell… So why it happened is the pheonix itself
In Pottermore it says that phoenix feather wands are known for occasionally generating magic seemingly on their own, and the golden fire is seen at the end between Harry and Voldemort in the final battle when Harry casts expeliarmus. Also the ring curse seems to be a curse that Voldemort placed on it (Dumbledore’s words) .
Alternate theory… wand cores. The Phoenix as we know is dumbeldores life long friend and guide. The chase happened just a month or two after his death. The wand recognized Voldemort as hating dumbeldore, and so reacted to that. I think it also had such a bond with Harry because he was “Dumbeldores man through and through ” so chose to defend his old master’s supporter, who was still grieving over the loss of his beloved headmaster. We know Voldemort stopped wanting his old wand after dumbeldore’s death, maybe the wand and Voldemort started to feel repulsed at one another. We don’t know enough about wand cores to say for sure, but that’s my guess. I like your theory too. Each are plausible
Taken directly from the hp wiki itself This was one of the rarest core types. Phoenix feathers were capable of the greatest range of magic, though they may have taken longer than either unicorn hair or dragon heartstring cores to reveal this. They showed the most initiative, sometimes acting of their own accord, a quality that many witches and wizards disliked. Notice how it says they sometimes act of their own accord? This can explain why Harry’s wand defended him from voldemort that night. Also, phoenixes are pretty much like the opposite of death. Instead of dying, they get reborn. This could explain why it was able to defend against voldemorts avada kedavra.
Love this theory would like to add to your explanation with the bit at the ministry where it doesnt happen, perhaps the reason it didn’t release the golden flame is because harry doesnt react in time. He did while flying trying to get away but not then so the horcrux coudn’t funnel its power thru harry. Its a thought a least. Great theory love you vids. Stay awesome.
If you ask me, I think this explanation makes perfect sense in terms of Harry’s Horcruxness. The soul embedded within the Horcrux will want to survive no matter what, it was created to persist and live on no matter who is trying to destroy it. As such, I feel the Horcrux is a distinct entity from the creator since they no longer share a body and therefore will fulfill its purpose of existing and persisting even after the death of its owner. The details are a smidge muddy if you ask me, but on the whole it makes sense
i think the explanation given by dumbledore in king cross was perfect. it was such a intriguing question, that the answer just seem to fit. the full explanation of dumbledore was”Having ensured this two-fold connection, having wrapped your destinies together more securely than ever two wizards were joined in history, Voldemort proceeded to attack you with a wand that shared a core with yours. And now something very strange happened, as we know. The cores reacted in a way that Lord Voldemort, who never knew that your wand was a twin of his, had never expected.” and then he says. “”I believe that your wand imbibed some of the power and qualities of Voldemort’s wand that night, which is to say that it contained a little of Voldemort himself. So your wand recognized him when he pursued you, recognized a man whowasbothkinandmortal enemy, and it regurgitated some of his own magic against him, magic much more powerful than anything Lucius’s wand had ever performed. Your wand now contained the power of your enormous courage and of Voldemort’s own deadly skill” so the main element int his scene was the twin cores acting the way they do, the horcrux part and mainly voldemort taking harry’s blood and ensuring a twin fold connection. as dumbledore says”is that harry and Lord Voldemort have journeyed together into realms of magic hitherto unknown and unprecedented”,so it was all these Factors that mattered.
I agree with this theory with one adjustment I actually think the reason that Harry’s wand didn’t react in the Ministry was because of Harry’s grief and love for Sirius. I think the depth of Harry’s feeling in the moment would have made the horcrux inside of him powerless. Just as the grief for Dobby at shell cottage seemed to close the connection between Harry and Voldemort although Dumbledore of course would have called it love.
Is it gold? I thought it was just the normal red of his Expelliarmus spell… Hmm. 2:23 I think maybe what Dumbledore was trying to say was, now that Harry bested Voldemort in a duel, and there is a PART of Voldemort INSIDE Harry’s wand… It doesn’t matter what wand Voldemort uses, because any wand can sense Voldemort’s energy inside Harry’s wand, and cannot willingly bring harm to their master. 5:07 Also, every offensive spell cast at Nagini just bounces straight off! Only the sword finishes it in the end, again, Basilisk poison and all that. Good article! Very interesting stuff!
I agree it was because Harry was a horcrux. In the book it desceibes how Harry felt his hand move on its own, without even knowing a spell was coming, and the hand with the wand automatically saves him. Think of it like the imperious curse, fogged brain, inability to fight it, just the body and soul acting in the way they need to.
In the scene where Harry’s wand wielding arm moves on its own and does a wand blast against Voldemort’s killing curse, among the distorted sound effects occurring due to Harry himself being incapacitated and rendered semi-conscious by his connection to Voldemort appears to be the squeaking/ringing sound associated commonly with Horcruxes. This same sound occurred right before Harry was about to be killed by Voldemort. This makes it very much likely that being a horcrux made Harry’s wand, which acts as an extension of himself, to react instinctively, though it is strange that he only reacted this way once and against Voldemort, unless Harry’s realization of being a horcrux allowed him to resist this instinctive reaction. This defensiveness, especially against Voldemort, is also likely due to Phoenix cores unleashing magic on their own and the fact that it’s the power and soul of Voldemort in the horcrux. Perhaps the horcrux tapped into the more unstable power of the wand and have the “extraordinary” power and soul of Voldemort to better exert more power from the wand.
I was recently re-reading the deathly hallows and I came across a bit more of an explanation as to why the wand shot out golden flames. On page 608 right after Harry and Voldemort cast Expelliarmus and Avada Kedavra respectively it describes golden flames where their spell meet. After reading this I began to come up with my own theory regarding the reason Harry’s wand shot out golden flames. Seeing as we know know golden flames are created when Avada Kedavra and Expelliarmus meet I believe that that is exactly what happened that night creating a very powerful explosion of magic. The explanation of this is I believe very similar to how Dumbledore described it in the book. That a bit of Voldemort’s wand’s power was transferred into Harry’s wand, that it sensed the presence of Voldemort and acted instinctively. That’s where my theory picks up I believe that due to there being two different powers within one wand that there were also two different instincts and because of that both powers resorted to each other’s most instinctual spells. Avada Kedavra and Expelliarmus. With both powers casting their spells at the same time out of the same wand it created a very powerful beam of golden fire. I could be wrong but that’s just my imagining of what happened.
My take is that when Harry and voldemort faced off in the graveyard and the twin wands collided with one another, the result of the stand off made the “victor’s” next spell against the other furore powerful than any spell the other uses. With that in mind, if harry won the stand off, his next spell towards voldemort will result in a success for Harry. As to why it didn’t activate until the Battle of the Seven Potters, it’s due to the fact that he hadn’t faced voldemort with a spell ever since their battle in the graveyard. Harry was prepared to defend himself in the ministry but wasn’t able to react in time and either way Dumbledore saved him.
Alright Ben, I almost entirely agree with you in the whole theory.. just a little glitch remains: At the “last” fight, when Voldie eventually dies, Harry was neither a horcrux nor the user of the Phoenix feather wand. Still his and Voldie’s spells collided and created same gold flames. How do you explain it; since Harry was no more a horcrux then?
I’m good with that theory. Also the Alow ahmora or however you spell it seems to be a spell that Hermione shows up knowing or at least it doesn’t seem that she would have learned it in class. We also know she knew spells already without even setting foot on Hogwarts (oculous repairo). The spell could have been rare enough that few knew it regardless of how easy it was to cast. Hermione, being the bookworm she was, may have come across it in her independent studies.
I think that at the point of Sirius’s death, Harry was already feeling helpless. He had no one left and felt, there was no point. He just wanted revenge at that point. I feel it was a mixture of Sirius’s death and Dumbledore being in the building that made the horcrux part of him not react. As you said, its a part of Harry, and Harry isn’t doing alright at this point. He’s mad and willing to die, just to prove a point. The horcrux part of him didn’t react. Because Harry didn’t care. He didn’t care if he lived or died.
I have a problem with that Order of Phoenix book explanation where you said that Horcrux inside Harry did not react because Harry felt safe. But a soul inside a Horcrux is said to have it’s own mind as they can defend themselves, it’s not the objects putting up a fight, it’s piece of soul putting up a fight through the object. Which means the soul inside Harry should have put up a fight as well coz the soul of Voldemort can think for itself and it wouldn’t have felt safe with Dumbledore coming to the Ministry. Same goes for Deathly Hallows death scene where Harry doesn’t defend himself. It doesn’t matter if Harry wanted to die or felt safe, Voldemort’s soul had it’s own way of sensing danger and should’ve reacted. Again, why didn’t Nagini try to protect itself when Neville destroyed it? Also, Riddle’s diary did not summon a Basilisk to protect itself, it did so because that’s what Voldemort meant to do with it. As per your argument about Liquid Luck, it’s not a wish granter, it can just bring odds in your favor, doesn’t mean you’ll win every time as we see in Half Blood Prince where Draco manages to infiltrate the school right under Ron, Hermione and Ginny’s nose who were under the influence of Liquid Luck. Also, you can’t take liquid luck too many times because it can have side effects. As per why Snape would’t take Liquid Luck, I always assumed it was because he was Practical man who believed in doing things for himself and not get lucky. Even if you don’t want to believe that, Snape probably thought that Dumbledore was the secret keeper seeing as how he was shocked that Potters were betrayed in his memories and probably thought Dumbledore would never give up their secret (Probably very few people knew who was their secret keeper at the time, others found out Sirius was secret keeper after he was captured and it wouldn’t make sense to tell everyone the identity of their secret keeper).
the one issue is how it was described,harry didnt even have a hold of his wand instead it turned all on its own like some kind of compass finding voldy and blasting a spell that was never seen again its not even fiendfire either and it isnt anything voldy has produced which means the horcrux shouldnt have been able to do that
it’s a horcrux that defended harry, but not Voldemort’s. that next article you said, of Dumbledore. Faux was his horcrux whose feather was used to make harry and voldemort’s wands. so it was Dumbledore who saved harry at the chase, it was him who saved harry at the ministry of defence, and of course he can counter voldemort’s death spell as dumbledore himself is the greatest wizard.
I think its actually the final remnants of the sacrificial protection love spell Lily placed on Harry to stop Voldemort from killing him, it only appeared 2 times because it was almost depleted after Harry had used it against Quirrell and when Voldemort broke through it in tbe graveyard when he touched Harrys Scar and could only be used Sparingly in times of great need, The Sky Battle was a great need as Harry had to fly a bike with an unconcious Hagrid while simultaneously fighting Voldemort with no back up or way out and the second and final time it appeared was when Harry was facing down Voldemort for the final time to kill him for good, and like you said it didnt protect Harry from Avada Kedavra in the forest because he was ready and willing to die and it didnt protect him at the Ministry because of his trust in Dumbledore
Alohamora doesn’t work on hexed/charmed locks. It just works on normal locks. I.e. umbridges office door was locked and secured with magic so alohamora wouldn’t do it. During the battle at he ministry while they were in he department of mysteries the kids used coloportus, the locking charm, the death eaters hat were after them couldn’t use alohamora on those doors..
Another thought has just occurred to me. Seeing as how wands have a certain aspect of self awareness to a degree Wat if the wand also recognized Lucius Malfoys wand seeing as how they were all made from ollivander himself. So I’m wondering if every wand that ollivander has made is able to recognize others wand made by ollivander. Like maybe when ollivander makes his wands that he possibly puts a bit of himself into each wand he makes. Sort of like his own little essence of some sort.
Just got an idea what if it was the fact voldemort created so many horcruxs that he couldn’t kill Harry? Both as a baby and as an adult. It seems to me that a wizards power, wand and soul are linked so splitting your soul necessarily weakens your power? So in the duel voldemort puts too much strain on his body/soul which may have been further weakened by the rest of his soul in the horcruxs already being destroyed, the soul begins to escape maybe trying to find a more stable host (again this may be because his soul is more likely to fracture after splitting it so many times), Harry’s wand recognised the foreign body and so expels it as extra magic (explaining what dumbledore said). As for baby Harry it might have been a combination of Lilly’s extra protection and voldermorts soul being able to easily fracture that made Harry a horcrux. The extra magic Lilly gave Harry was enough to put enough strain on voldermorts soul that it begins to weaken and escape, off guard and weekend by horcruxs voldermorts spell back fires killing his body (he’s still too powerful to be fully destroyed by his own magic unlike later on where he has Harry’s magic also attacking him)
I just found something while I was rereading CoS. In CoS, when Harry stabs the basillisk and kills him, one of it’s fangs stabs Harry’s arm and almost kills him (but didn’t because of Fawks). And then he proceeds to stab the diary with said fang, which destrous the horcrux. But if Harry himself is a horcrux, then wouldn’t the basillisk poison destroy the horcrux within Harry, and Fawks tears save Harry’s life? Or did the tears save the horcrux as well?
Wait, I just wanted to say Ben that there are plenty of good reasons for locks. When they imprison someone in Azkaban they take away their wand, and break it. So they couldn’t get out of the cell they were in, by just using the alohomora charm. Only the dementors, and guards and such could get in. Just wanted to point that out.
I couldn’t remember the exact article you guys said this. But you were explain how Harry defended himself against voldermort, by saying that he is a horcrux. I agree with this and it is confirmed that he is a horcrux. But if you re-watch the 1st Deathly Hollows and listen very closely you can hear the sound that is used in the 2nd Deathly Hollows when Harry comes in contact with the other horcruxes. To me it sounds like brake pads squealing. Sorry for the long explanation but I’ve been trying to learn more about the potterverse and have watched all of yours and a few other YouTubers theory articles, explaintion articles, etc. Hope all is well and that you wouldn’t mind chatting so I could learn more. Sincerely, Ben Cooper
The night Harry is orphaned: Lily’s magic latches onto him with the order: Protect. The Voldemort fragment’s magic holds the order: empower. The soul fragment empowers harry to protect itself from destruction, lily’s magic protects harry from his own mortality. Most likely each are anchored to his soul somewhat (Horcruxes are soul magic and lily’s spell protects harry’s life), thus perhaps the two powers acted together: protect and empower. This would create a supernatural spell fuelled from 3 different cores all anchored to Harry’s own core (no spell can exist without without a core to feed off) even the wards of places like hogwarts feed off the core of the magical leylines. Lily and voldemort’s magic and horcrux acted upon the intent they are given and like with the quirell molten hands, generated a blast of intense heat to eliminate the threat of death.
If Dumbledore made a horcrux, it was Fawkes (fan theory and covered by the SC brothers). Now Fawkes only gave 2 feathers and Ollivander produced 2 wands from them. Therefore, a bit of Dumbledore’s soul resides in both Voldemort’s and Harry’s wand. In Order of the Phoenix, the horcrux wand doesn’t defend itself (and Harry the horcrux) because Dumbledore’s horcrux (Harry’s wand) knows Dumbledore is there. It knows, it feels and it doesn’t sense imminent danger. In Deathly Hallows, golden flames (Fawkes’ fire) shoot from Harry’s wand when Voldemort fires the killing curse at him. Dumbledore’s horcrux is defending itself and, by default, Harry the horcrux. Help will always be given to those who ask for it…
There is a hudge hole in that explanation – why the horcrux inside Harry defend itself only from Voldemort? Harry was in mortal danger a couple of times and the golden flames only appeared once, in Voldemorts presence. Unless its about intensity of emotions, but you’d have to argue that other times Harry was in danger he didn’t feel as strong fear/ helplesness as that night. (Also I love your website, thank you for expanding Harry Potter Universe for me ❤️)
The reason that Harry’s wand produces golden flames is because the wand is a horcrux, and is protecting its self. Fauwks was Dumbledor’s horcrux and part of Dumbledor’s soul is in Harry and Voldermort’s wands because the wands have Fauks’s feathers as cores. The flames that came out of Harry’s wand were gold, like Phoenix flames. The reason it only does this now is because Voldermort’s not using his own wand, unlike other times when he tried to kill Harry. Harry’s wand has never tried to protect its self before because A- Harry was protecting it himself, and B- the horcrux in Harry’s wand recognised that Voldermort’s wand contained part of the same persons soul, so it would not try to destroy Voldermort’s wand.
I think the wand produced flames because it recognized Voldemort and recognized that he had a different wand thus could kill Harry, but the wand still recognized Voldemort as the owner of it’s twin so just as it did when they first fought it didn’t want to be defeated by someone associated with it’s twin therefore it produced golden flames which it could do because of how it was made with a phoenix feather, it only used this ability in that situation because of how it was facing the owner of its twin, maybe it was angry or insulted by the usage of another wand
Huh. Makes sense to me, as Harry’s essentially a “phoenix”: didn’t die from the Dursley’s abuse/neglect (which is hinted at to be pretty graphic at times. Petunia tried hitting him on the head with a freaking frying pan at least once), his wand’s core is literally a phoenix feather (and produces golden and scarlet sparks…heeeyyy, golden flames!), Harry’s insane luck, Fawkes coming to the rescue, oh and of course surviving a direct hit from the killing curse TWICE
@SuperCarlinBrothers I have to disagree a little with you on this one. About the horcrux not defending itself in the forest I don’t think it’s so much following Harry’s decision, as it doesn’t really have a choice. I think it comes back to what Dumbledore says that “because to confide a part of your soul to something that can think and move for itself is obviously a very risky business” and I believe the “think” part is key here. The fact that Harry thinks about it, and chooses to not defend, actively doesn’t do it, means that the horcrux can’t actually force his arm up. In the motorcycle Harry is lost, and doesn’t do anything, so the horcrux can move his muscles. In the ministry, as you said, Harry had decided he was safe by the mere fact that Dumbledore was there, and was therefore in control of his muscles as well.
I think the short of it is that harry and tom shared the weirdest possible connection in the whole history of magic. You take an already quirky system like magic, push its internal logic to the utmost and then some more. At this point Harry was connected to Voldemort by the prophecy, the promise Voldemort gave to Snape, the subsequent old magic protection spell cast by lily, the piece of soul attached to harry making him a horcrux, Harrys blood being used to create voldemorts new body, the priori incantatem due to them sharing a wand core, the whole wand ownership deal that comes in additionally, the scar that was created by one of the most powerful spells that can never fail failing on harry. The same way very weird stuff happens when you push physics to its utmost limits and suddenly quantum effects show up. Or you feed tons of unexpected, extremely unlikely variables into a software that is already a hot mess of updates, hot fixes and botches. Sometimes really unexpected stuff pops out. It is not surprising that it doesn’t conform to the internal logic of the magic system. Actually it would be weird if it did apply to the logic of modern magic. You have to remember that the modern magic we see taught in Hogwarts is basically a set of rules applied to the older, more powerful natural magic to make it easier to use and more predictable. Thats one of the reasons why some of the old artifacts that are still around are so powerful and…quirky. They come from a time before the wizarding world added their patch on top of the old system.
Harry Potter has a magic system with literally no boundaries. You could explain anything and everything with…. magic. Check out The Kingkiller Chronicles it’s a Harry Potter-esque story “family dies goes to school to learn magic” but more elegant, beautiful, and complex in its written word. It’s more sophisticated essentially, as much as it pains me to use that term. A true masterpiece in Fantasy. Many amazing theories too. The magic systems are actually explained. Sympathy, Sygaldry, Naming, etc. Kvothe is a boss.
I always looked at Aloha Morra as a newer spell that was either kept from the general public or developed recently and instead of just getting rid of all the locks they just left them in to save time and effort. Also if it was the horcrux creating the golden flames why are they only ever seen that one time harry is in clear danger of dying many times in the series but we only ever see the flames that one time.
In the books liquid luck is explained. That it only works when u rarely use it. And it’s against wizzed law to take it unless a normal day, thus why u may not keep it on hand. Slughorn used it twice in his life. I agree on horcrux theory Dumbledore left it open because he didn’t want Harry to have the information to early.
I agree but to an extent I believe that the reason why having a living hoecrucs is so dangeruse because if they choose not to defend they don’t have to but if they are in mortal danger and choose to defend the hoecrucs will direct the hosed under like a anatomet object that can’t choose to defend or not to
I can get on board with the whole horcrux defending itself… Obviously we’ve seen countless times in the books where they do this… Just other things don’t make sense when it happens to other people like in the fight at Hogwarts or in the ministry (I think both, but I know it happens in one of these places) the wands connect which in my understanding can only happen in rare circumstances aka twin tail feathers….
I have thought about this very puzzle for years. My conclusion is that both Harry’s wand and Harry himself was NOT prepared to die (during the chase) and therefore both his wand and himself fought back. Old Voldy was still using his wand, not Malfoys. It wasn’t until later that Voldy TOOK Malfoys wand, he didn’t WIN it, so even then Malfoys wand WOULD NOT HAVE WORKED for him. That wand did not change its allegiance. What do you think of my theory?
Wait the diary’s defense is to summon the Basilisk? Does that mean if someone had the means to destroy it outside of Hogwarts it would have conjured the serpent there, or would the Basilisk find a way out of the chamber and somehow magically travel to the location where the diary was being attacked? If that’s the case Voldemort should have just sealed the diary in the chamber with the Basilisk and never let it out and with it literally living with the serpent it would always be in a protected area.
It makes even more sense when you consider that the Harry Horcrux was the only one created accidentally. All of the others were made deliberately, and so may have an element of cooperation, even if only on an unconscious level. The Harry Horcrux isn’t a part of that. It was made uncaringly; you could even call it a neglectful abandonment on Voldemort’s part when he made it. It then follows that, although he would never have a reason to, Voldemort theoretically could have acted to destroy his other Horcruxes and they wouldn’t have acted to defend themselves. The Harry Horcrux is the only one with an attitude of “Well screw you, too” towards Voldemort, and would be the only one to act against him.
when you tried explaining the fire reading straight from the phone i had what was explained all mapped out in my head. wish i was good with animation or had a good camera casue then i could articles the entire explanation i came up with that doesn’t involve the horcrux. but it does make more sense. if you want my explanation i will article it for you to look at.
However if the defense abilities of a horcrux caused by a complex set of spells when creating it, then Harry acting as a horcrux in self defense doesn’t make sense since he is not a well made horcrux, he just got a piece of Voldemort’s soul and nothing else. I would say: Lily’s protection was to break that night right ? (I think I remember it right) So what if that’s literally the leftover power from that.
I believe that those golden flames are connected to the room in the department of mysteries that cannot be opened. Harry tried to pick the lock but it came back melted … so the fire would make sense. Dumbledore references that Harry has a special power (probably love) that takes up a room in the DOM. I think that this special power EITHER comes from the protection charm that lily cast on harry when she died OR its Ancient magic created by the Three Brothers that can only be accessed by their descendants (Voldemort, Gaunt Family, Potter Family, Dumbledore etc.)
I don’t have a satisfactory reason why Fawks’ tail feather wand might have chosen Voldemort, yet. Still puzzling over that one (yes, I’ve seen the SCB article on the subject and it was really good but not didn’t entirely answer for me why Voldemort might’ve been chosen at all so that’s a gaping blank for me) . But, what if the reason it chose Harry was the same reason it chose Voldemort… because of the Horcrux. And thereafter, the SCB theory from this article explains the wands’ behavior. Not only do wands with twin cores already have an affinity for each other that makes them dislike battling each other, but in addition these two particular wands also recognize that both owners are the same person in a way. Doesn’t seem as convincing now I write it out because I really liked the SCB theory about Goodrich Griffindor being Fawks’ previous owner and the whole “Slytherin / Griffindor” friendship/rivalry and this kind of discounts that. 🤷🏼♀️
Except the horcrux does not defend Harry when he shows up for his death at the battle of hogwarts. So this theory lacks consistency. Dumbledore’ statement seems more in line that it had something to do with the wand. We are also informed or suggested that there is a form of intelligence based in the wands, the “wand chooses the wizard”. This is resolved by Rowling by having Harry’s wand broken, so it is no longer around later in the story when Harry encounters Voldemort again. It does seem a bit odd. But at the same time the priori incantatum chapter was a one of a kind type of event. And in that conflict the two wizards were strugling to push the “bead” back into the other, which would have some sort of consequence. Order of the Pheonix scene would have likely ended with the same event in Goblet of Fire. The difference is the spell does not reach Harry. The wand does react because the wands were about to link up again (as Voldemort was using his wand). I would argue though the reason Voldemort does not have the same “ability” as Harry is less to do with the fact that he lost. It more has to do with the fact he is no longer using his wand when he confronts Harry. In his attempt to bypass the wand magic that tied them together last time (which he saw as a fluke) he inadvertently put himself at a huge disadvantage because he didn’t understand wand lore/magic. Golden flames also does not seem like a very “Horcrux” type magic. Tie in the fact that you in other articles claim Harry is a Philolsphers Stone analog, the golden flame is more tied to him.
The Golden flames that we see just once are the manifestation called as Priori Incantatem, that happens when 2 wands share the same core and the same origin are forced to fight each other. Is just that, as Dumbledore explained to Harry in the 4th tone And the reason we see them just once it’s because Voldemort sucks out this same info from Olivander and changed wands from that point on
Think about it as the fact that at that point Harry too was a part of Voldemort, and because the wand imbued powers of Voldemort it became reactive to Voldemort as in it already bested him once and it would have been almost as to Voldemorts duelling against each other neither part of Voldemort wanted to lose and because of that in a subconscious state that part of Harry was able to be taken over remember the horcruxs defend themselves against anything trying to harm it so just a thought
Alright, let’s see. 1st. In GoF when Riddle and Harry fight, there’s a point when Riddle’s wand starts spewing out echoes. A hand, and “ghosts” of some people. I HIGHLY doubt that is all that happened during those moments. Harry’s wand stole a few things as well. Either from the wand, or Riddle himself. 2nd. Now fast forward to DH, Harry gets chased by Riddle, and one point gets Very disoriented and his wand decided to Use some of what it stole two years previous.
If all of the Horcruxes defend themselves by producing the Golden Flames than it all makes sense. Dumbledore created a Horcrux. He’s Phoenix was his Horcrux AND feathers of that particualar phoenix were the cores of Voldemort’s and Harry’s wands. So it could be said that small parts of Dumbledore’s soul were also in these wands. That would explain wands recognising each other and sensing familiarity and all this protecting/ overpowering stuff (Harry was also a Horcrux).
Actually Dumbledores explanation makes perfect sense, because if you had been paying attention, the wand not only chooses the wizard but it is also only as powerful as the magic user who wields it. Meaning taking both of those into account a wand is somewhat self aware yes, but its true nature is only to focus a witch or wizards power into spells and hexes, which in turn means that a wand has no true magical power of its own, now muggles have been known to get a wand to discharge sparks out of the end of one when they play with it, but if you think about it, it only does this because no matter how new a wand is it has already been in the hands of a witch or wizard and that would be the wandsmith, I know this much because wand making is a craft not an industry, which means every single wand is made by hand not mass produced. Now a wand only performs at its best when in the hands of the witch or wizard it chose because if it were in the hands of another it would be out of focus and incapable of producing the same effect for the imposter, which is why when Ron got a new wand at ollivanders in the prisoner of Azkaban(he had been using his brother Charlies old one up until that point) he was better at focusing his magic and why Neville after the battle of the department of mysteries was quite a bit less of a joke because the wand he had been using up until then had been his fathers wand and it was snapped during the battle which forced his grandmother to buy him a new one(he couldn’t use his mothers because that was destroyed when she tried to fight off bellatrix lestrange, her husband(Rodolphus lestrange, who died in Azkaban for this crime), and Barty crouch junior before Bellatrix tortured her and nevilles father into insanity(nevilles parents names were Alice and Frank longbottom,) so if the rest of you think you are true potter heads try that on for size) .
Nice!! I disagree though with the reasoning for the horcrux not defending itself in book 5. The real difference is that Harry & his wand were not at the ready and so there was no way to website the power from the horcrux – as the book tells us, his mind was blank and his wand was pointing uselessly at the floor. (Fact is, nothing would have happened to Harry anyway, because as we know, Voldemort’s living body tethers him to life, but it’s very convenient that Dumbledore was on hand anyway.) In the battle of the seven Harrys, he is positioned to fight but has no idea what to do and is feeling helpless. Enter, horcrux Harry. I do agree, though, that his willingness to die when facing Voldemort in the forest is what exposes the horcrux to danger without the ability to defend itself.
i think that there was a golden flame because harry and voldemort’s wands are twins as their core is made from the same phonix faurx. also because the wands are twins in the last book (harry potter and the deathly hallows) voldemort tries to get the elder wand from dumbledore’s grave as he knows that he cant beat harry with his own wand
I think you missed on it. The twin wands can’t hurt each other because it would be akin to hurting itself. A Phoenix is a highly spiritual creature and Olivander himself believes wands are sentient in some way. In Legacy Ominus is able to navigate the school because of the sentience of his wand. A sentient wand would refuse to hurt its brother or sister. The Golden flames are from the Phoenix itself. Check amd mate
When Harry looks into the Pensive after Snapes death, it shows snape talking to dumbledores portrait, as if he is still alive. This also continuously happens with other paintings around the castle. I think it is confusing, as they seem to have a conscience similar to that of a ghost at hogwarts. Any ideas how this is possible?
Maybe there’s already an answer to this, but talking about wands… Would there have been another wand to choose Harry if he was not a horcrux? I’m pretty sure his wand choosed him because a part of its twins owner was in Harry. And does Harrys wand work less well after Voldemorts Soul in Harry got killed?
SuperCarlinBrothers I have often wondered, if The Wand can choose The Wizard, Then The Wand must have some level of magical awareness {?} . If so, could Voldemort’s Wand have grown weary of the Dark Magic? After all, after He returned did he ever truly perform a successful great and powerful spell… ?
When a wizard clashes with another wizard like harry and voldemort did the colour of the spell that they used for example glacius glacius is a spell to freeze people in a block of ice so there fore it should be cyan or blue voldemort uses avada kedavra and its green so expelliarmus maybe a reddish golden? idk but thats what i think
It’s pretty funny to me that the Golden Flames are basically just Harry’s horcruxe-ness getting defensive, even if it’s… against another shred of Voldemort, as in the main one. Like the Voldemort shred inside Harry finally did him a solid and went “Oh man this is bad, no twin cores, no Dumbledore, this might actually kill us kid, you now what? I’ll just take over for a second to keep us alive, you owe me, wonder who’s trying to kill us though, weird. anyway, GILDED FLAME”
One sentence of Dumbledore just made me think: I believe that your wand imbided some of the powers and qualities of Voldemort’s wand that night, which is to say that it contained a little of Voldemort himself. This somehow sounds like Harry’s wand himself may have been a horcrux as well? Sadly I can’t come up with any proofs for that… but maybe you guys can?